News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple loses copyright battle against security startup Cor... by ineedasername on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @09:04PM (#25577510)
That's an interesting ruling, but seems overly broad to allow an entirely unlicensed copy simply because there are (apparently extensive) debugging tools incorporated into the emulation. Then again, this sort of debugging it already possible on less locked-down OS's with valid paths to licensing them. I like the end result, but not the means by which this ruling gets there: I'd rather something like compulsory licensing under reasonable terms for certain purposes like this, something along the lines of the system used for compulsory licensing in music.
Re:Apple loses copyright battle against security startup Cor... by gorkish on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @09:18PM (#25577611)
Can’t legislate from the bench. But there already is a subtext here. If one could license iOS for this, what they are doing here probably wouldn’t fall under fair use. Instead it could fall under the terms of Apple’s own license agreement. I’m personally kind of sick of Apple’s shit in the virtualization/emulation/kernel/cloud/hackintosh/thumb-on-developers area though, and I fully realize my bias to applaud this decision regardless of whether or not it is fair or right to Apple or whether Cornelium deserved to win. Seems there is a lot of smoke billowing out of this thing...
Re:Apple loses copyright battle against security startup Cor... by ineedasername on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @11:14PM (#25578443)
Yes, I'd rather see legislation to resolve this issue as well.
Re:Apple loses copyright battle against security startup Cor... by EMIRELADERO on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @09:08PM (#25577540)
The whole point of this is that it should be debuggable without any permission from the copyright holder.
Re:Apple loses copyright battle against security startup Cor... by ineedasername on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @11:16PM (#25578459)
I agree, which is why I would rather a legal framework of compulsory licensing. This seems an overly broad interpretation of fair use.