News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:20 Years Later by pontus on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @07:03PM (#25576679)
Disclaimer: My background is in string theory.

I've spent a lot of time thinking about this subject (in fact, I studied string theory at Columbia which is where Peter Woit is). The main issue that people have with string theory is the lack of testability / falsifiability. I think there's definitely some issues there, but I think blaming string theory is not quite right.

There are two reasons why string theory is tough to test. One of them, and the most obvious one, is that the energy scale where the strings exist is super high (likely at or near the Planck scale). This means that if we wanted to detect the direct signatures of strings, we'd have to create an experiment that is sensitive to these energy scales. This seems to be completely infeasible (people talk about particle colliders having to be the size of our solar system etc.) Now, interestingly this is not actually only a problem with string theory but rather with any theory of quantum gravity. This is because the fundamental scale of a theory is usually determined by combining its fundamental constants in some way as to produce an energy scale, and any theory of quantum gravity must somehow contain Planck's constant, Newton's constant of gravitation, and the speed of light. Taking these together gives you the Planck scale.

So, in other words if the reason you don't want to study string theory is that it only is testable at the Planck scale, then what you're really saying is that you don't think we should study any theory of quantum gravity. This is, I think, way to extreme of a position.

Now, interestingly, string theory is actually more than a theory of gravity, so unlike something like e.g. loop quantum gravity which is only a theory of gravity, it's conceivable that string theory somehow within it contains information that "trickles down" to lower energies and thus could potentially be testable at something like the LHC. This leads me to the second reason why string theory is very difficult to test.

It turns out that the equations of string theory are more-or-less unique at high energies but that as you start lowering the energy at which you probe the theory, multiple distinct solutions emerge. These solutions turn out to have a very nice physical interpretation: they are the different ways in which we can compactify the extra dimensions of string theory. Regardless of this physical interpretation, the fact remains that there are many many distinct solutions of string theory at low energies, and in order to make predictions that are falsifiable, we need to know which of these solutions we're living in. This is where the crux of the problem lies. It turns out that there are so many solutions of string theory that we cannot even in principle go through them one at a time to see if they're feasible (people throw around the number 10^500).

Now, it turns out that the real problem is not actually in the number of distinct solutions to string theory (~10^500), but rather in the way their structure is poorly understood. In fact, any theory of physics contains an infinite number of theories within it. For example, consider the mass of the electron as a free parameter. Until I tell you what the mass is, you can't make a complete prediction for what the energy levels in Hydrogen are. In fact, you could argue that since the mass of the electron is a real number, there are in fact an infinite number of predictions to the energy levels. A bit sarcastically you could then say that at least string theory has "only" 10^500 different theories within it, unlike traditional physics that has this continuous infinite set of theories.

The distinction between these two cases is then that for traditional theories, we can go the other way. If we measure the energy levels of Hydrogen, we can infer the mass of the electron. Then, knowing the mass of the electron, we can make other predictions. It's this last step that's currently missing in string theory. Currently we only know how to move in one direction: give me the solution you're talking about and I might be able to make predictions, but give me observational data and I can't work backwards to determine which solution I'm in. It's almost like a one-way hash.

I would say that this last objection is a roadblock that we're currently facing, and it's not perfectly clear that it's not solvable, nor is it clear that it is. I think that until we solve this problem, string theory will be stuck and people will be pointing fingers at the theory calling it a fool's errand. I personally think this criticism is misguided.

The upshot of this is that most people who work on string theory work in areas that are not plagued by this bifurcation to low energies. For example, you can use string theory to study the structure and behavior of black holes and holography, something called AdS/CFT, an area that has been incredibly successful.

Re:20 Years Later by mmmBacon on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @07:50PM (#25577021)
I think your post is well thought out but you are hand waving a bit too much over string theory’s inability to reduce to known results. Reduction is an important cornerstone in physics and it’s a way to validate if a theory is on the right track even when things are not measurable.

I do not think it is correct to say that special relativity for example gives 10^500 possible classical theories. We know special relativity needs to produce same outcome as Newtonian mechanics or Maxwell’s equations in the limit as velocity tends to 0. In my simple example, we have 2 well established theories which bound the possible outcomes. This is all possible even without knowing the speed of light.

Re:20 Years Later by pontus on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:29AM (#25578880)
I agree that it's important to be able to reproduce existing theories. What I don't think is fair is to say that because we have not yet figured out a way to perform this reduction we should throw the theory out. There's a difference between a theory being untestable even in principle and being untestable because we have not yet understood the theory well enough.

I like the analogy of a hash function. Imagine that someone gave you the exact specification of a hash function (e.g. sha256) as well as the hash value of a list of inputs. The only thing missing from the story is the salt that was used in hashing the inputs. You're asked to make a prediction of what ought to happen when you hash the string "hello", but unless you know the salt you can't figure it out. So, you study all the examples provided and try to find collisions so that you can figure out what the salt is. The problem is that while it's easy to hash values, it's very hard to find collisions. It's really frustrating because in some sense you have all the information you need, but unless you're able to find vulnerabilities in sha256, you can't move forward. So, you spend a lot of time trying to understand what this hash function is really doing. Maybe some day you'll crack it at which point you'll be able to figure out the salt and ultimately make your prediction. However, until that day people around you keep telling you that you're being silly because your theory lacks predictive power. They say things like "your theory can predict anything you want it to, just pick your favorite salt and it'll output whatever you want!". It's not that the theory is necessarily wrong, it's that you don't fully understand it yet.

Re:20 Years Later by gwerbret on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:00AM (#25579602)
> There's a difference between a theory being untestable even in principle and being untestable because we have not yet understood the theory well enough.

If the theory is neither testable nor verifiable, then how do you (or anyone else) know you're even on the right track?

Re:20 Years Later by stevenhuang on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @05:03AM (#25580305)
> because we have not _yet_ understood the theory well enough

Keep working on it? You won't know until you take it to the end, or at at least until other theories show promise.

Re:20 Years Later by codethief on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @09:01PM (#25577490)
As someone who usually is rather critical of string theory I like your post a lot. I could come up with other criticism of string theory that your post does not cover, but you do present some very good points. That being said, I disagree with the following bit:

> For example, you can use string theory to study the structure and behavior of black holes and holography, something called AdS/CFT, an area that has been incredibly successful.

Here, "successful" only means that other (famous) string theorists have found those ideas worth pursuing. Then, other people, in turn, picked up the idea because the former people had praised it and then they, too, would receive praise. (It's almost like what people on Reddit call, pardon my French, a circle jerk.) However, AdS/CFT hasn't produced a single bit of verifiable experimental evidence in the realm of black holes. It's not even clear what AdS/CFT has to do with our (clearly non-AdS!) universe.

Re:20 Years Later by pontus on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:17AM (#25578831)
Yes, when I say that AdS/CFT is successful, I definitely am not saying that we have a falsifiable prediction for black holes, but I also don't mean that these are simply results that famous physicists like and promote, it's a bit deeper than that.

For many years it was conjectured that gravitation is actually most clearly understood as a two-dimensional theory (people call this the principle of holography). The rationale is that the entropy of a black hole is proportional to its area rather than its volume. Since a black hole is in a very specific sense the object of maximum entropy, that means that the amount of information that we can store in space is not proportional to its volume, but rather the area of the encompassing "sphere". This is super surprising since it suggests that what we perceive as 3d is really just an illusion and that the correct formulation of physics ought to be a 2d theory.

Now, for a long time we didn't have a way to actually write this sort of duality down. We sort of knew one side of the story (gravity with general relativity), but it fails in precisely the domains where we want to investigate it (black holes). String theory, whether you believe it's the true theory of everything or not, is nonetheless a mathematically consistent theory of quantum gravity (in a sense it's at least an existence proof that gravity can consistently be quantized). As such, it's at the very minimum a great arena to analyze these problems carefully. The first explicit construction of the duality between a 3d theory of quantum gravity and a 2d theory without gravity is precisely AdS/CFT. It says that a quantum theory of gravity is AdS space is mathematically and physically equivalent to a 2d theory of a conformal field theory that lives in 2d.

I don't think it's fair to say that AdS/CFT is being studied because famous people like it. It really does have a lot of value if nothing else than as a playground to understand how one could in principle formulate these dualities consistently.

Re:20 Years Later by codethief on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:33PM (#25588113)
I mostly agree with what you're saying but still, the entire "success story" of AdS/CFT is based on other assumptions about quantum gravity none of which has been tested experimentally. Even black hole entropy itself is, up until now, a purely theoretical construct.

> String theory […] is nonetheless a mathematically consistent theory

I hear this claim being perpetuated a lot but I have yet to see a string theorist give a mathematically rigorous introductory lecture on string theory. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying there are no mathematically precise results in the realm of string theory but I know enough about functional analysis and the issues surrounding the mathematical underpinnings of quantum field theory (or even quantum mechanics) that I'm not buying your claim and my current view is that some parts of string theory are very rigorous, whereas (most) others are not. (AdS/CFT is one such part which belongs to the latter category.) I'd love to be proven wrong, though, so please feel free to send me papers etc.

Re:20 Years Later by pontus on Thursday December 31, 2020 @10:52AM (#25593731)
Ok, when I say mathematically consistent I don't mean it in an axiomatic sense. In fact, like you point out there is a lot of unanswered questions even within quantum field theory whether or not it's mathematically well defined. In fact, one of the millennium prizes is related to this.

When I say mathematically consistent, I mean it in a looser sense. If we take a step back to before string theory, there was no way to get consistent results from quantum gravitational calculations. The usual tools that we use to renormalize quantum field theories do not work for gravity. This suggests that there's some type of "ultraviolet completion" of general relativity. In other words, the theory of GR ought to come with some implicit energy cutoff beyond which the theory somehow changes. String theory is such a change in that the stringy corrections to GR would only come into effect around the Planck scale. It's by no means necessarily the unique such completion, but as of now it's the only one we know of.

As to your other point, I think it's a good idea to reframe the work done in string theory as (what I used to joke) "theoretical theoretical physics". In other words, it may be the case that string theory is a true theory of nature, but even if it isn't, the theory lets us explore what such consistent theories could look like and how various paradoxes (like the information paradox in black holes) get resolved. These types of insights may point us in a direction of further investigation that may very well fall outside string theory.

In other words, at the very least (and I personally think this is underselling string theory by a lot) string theory is a proof of concept and a very powerful, sophisticated, and rich arena in which we can begin to understand the salient features of quantum gravity. One such example is AdS/CFT.

Re:20 Years Later by whatshisface on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @09:09PM (#25577550)
It's producing results in strongly coupled field theories. You take strong coupled physics, translate it to AdS, solve it and translate it back. Then you get answers for problems like the dynamics of quark-gluon plasma.
Re:20 Years Later by codethief on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @09:19PM (#25577615)
I am aware of that. Which is why I tried being very precise with my words:

> However, AdS/CFT hasn't produced a single bit of verifiable experimental evidence in the realm of black holes

Re:20 Years Later by whatshisface on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @11:45PM (#25578655)
Given that there have been exactly zero experiments conducted in laboratories close to black holes, isn't that qualifier kind of a cop-out? Our entire observational knowledge of black holes consists of radiation emitted from the accretion disk (deep in the classical regime), orbits of nearby objects (even farther in the classical regime), and one blurry radio picture (predicted by GR and containing nothing, yet, to our knowledge, outside of GR's predictions.) I guess you could count gravitational waves, but guess what, that's GR too... ;) Given the observational knowledge of today, even a true theory of quantum gravity beamed back from the future would fail to produce verifiable experimental evidence in the realm of black holes.
Re:20 Years Later by codethief on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:17PM (#25587991)
> Given that there have been exactly zero experiments conducted in laboratories close to black holes, isn't that qualifier kind of a cop-out?

No, I don't think it is. I agree of course that it's hard to test predictions regarding black holes. But I was addressing OP's statement that

> For example, you can use string theory to study the structure and behavior of black holes and holography, something called AdS/CFT, an area that has been incredibly successful.

and I merely intended to express my disagreement with the claim that AdS/CFT has been "incredibly successful". Successful in what way? Measured by what metric? Clearly not by the usual metric that says that experimental evidence is what counts. And on top of all of that AdS isn't even close to the spacetime describing the known universe.

> Given the observational knowledge of today, even a true theory of quantum gravity beamed back from the future would fail to produce verifiable experimental evidence in the realm of black holes.

I don't think this is necessarily true. See, for instance, https://backreaction.blogspot.com/2020/01/how-to-test-quantu...

Re:20 Years Later by sampo on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @08:10PM (#25577160)
> These solutions turn out to have a very nice physical interpretation: they are the different ways in which we can compactify the extra dimensions of string theory. Regardless of this physical interpretation, the fact remains that there are many many distinct solutions of string theory at low energies, and in order to make predictions that are falsifiable, we need to know which of these solutions we're living in.

You have created a mathematical structure that is so flexible that it can fit any data. It is useless. You have abandoned the hypothetico-deductive model.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothetico-deductive_model

Re:20 Years Later by whatshisface on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @08:44PM (#25577380)
Isn't math itself a mathematical structure flexible enough to fit any data?
Re:20 Years Later by damoe on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @09:36PM (#25577742)
Perhaps, but that would be one reason why mathematics is not physics.
Re:20 Years Later by whatshisface on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @11:36PM (#25578602)
String theory is moreso considered a framework that may lead to physics than a physical theory. Physicists are interested in it because of its potential to lead to physics. Of course, both of these statements are contained in the original comment. That's why, as the original comment suggests, the absolute most important question about string theory is, "which string theory leads to our universe at low energies?"
Re:20 Years Later by knuthsat on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:16AM (#25579694)
Why isn't it possible to go through some kind of a search tree and prune the solution set?

I guess to parametrize the theory it takes something other than masses of elementary particles and a few constants?

If I had that big of a solution set I'd definitely try to search through it. If one string theory solution can give me a predict() function that I can verify, I'll find a way to parametrize it (deep neural networks, graph data structures) and then check if predict() matches the predictions we know.

Re:20 Years Later by pontus on Friday January 01, 2021 @06:24PM (#25608418)
That would be nice, the problem is that nobody has a good way of doing that. Like the analogy I gave elsewhere, it's sort of like a hash function: doable to compute in one direction but seemingly impossible to invert. If that's the case it's be very difficult to create such a tree to prune because there's no way to categorize the nodes. In other words, the depth of the tree would be 1 and the breadth would be ~10^500.
Re:20 Years Later by knuthsat on Saturday January 02, 2021 @06:36AM (#25612093)
Interesting, the first thing that I assumed was that it's easy to compare one solution to another and get a nice finegrained comparison. For example, a set of solutions with some parameter is always inferior to another set with a better parametrization.
Re:20 Years Later by daxfohl on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @07:19PM (#25576781)
I'm confused on your last point. If indeed string theory is wrong, doesn't that invalidate everything we've learned about black holes and holography via AdS/CFT too?
Re:20 Years Later by ywei3410 on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @11:42PM (#25578639)
Could you elaborate a little further on what you mean by a fundamental scale of a theory being related to it's constants please?
Re:20 Years Later by pontus on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:06AM (#25578776)
Sure!

So, take as a silly example a regular pendulum of mass m and length l swinging on earth where the acceleration due to gravity is g.

Suppose we want to figure out what the period of the pendulum is (i.e. how long it takes for it to make one full swing from left to right back to left).

We could go ahead and solve this by using Newton's laws, but at the end of the day whatever formula we find should have within it the parameters mentioned above (as well as regular numbers like 2s, pis, etc.). If we take a look at the units of the parameters above, we see:

mass of pendulum (m): kg

length of pendulum (l): m

acceleration due to gravity (g): m/s^2

Out of these we want to produce something with units of time, and it turns out that there's a unique way of combining the above to get that: 1/g has units of s^2/m, so l/g will have units of s^2. Just take the square root and you find sqrt(l/g).

Now, this doesn't necessarily mean that the period of the pendulum is exactly sqrt(l/g), it just means that it needs to be proportional to this. In fact the formula for the period has an extra factor of 2pi in it: 2pi sqrt(l/g). The point is that the general magnitude you'd expect for any timescale associated with the pendulum would be roughly equal to sqrt(l/g).

For quantum gravity the story is the same. We have some parameters that we expect should be deeply part of any prediction: Planck's constant, the speed of light, Newton's constant of gravitation. The units are as follows:

Planck's constant (hbar): m^2 kg / s

Speed of light (c): m/s

Gravity (G): m^3 / kg s^2

From these we want to figure out what the relevant energy scale is (i.e. when will this theory start differing from a non quantum mechanical version of gravity). Well, there's only one way to combine these into an expression that has the dimensions of energy. This particular way of combining the constants is huge and is traditionally called the Planck scale:

E_Pl ~ sqrt(hbar c^5 / G) ~ 10^19 GeV

In contrast, the LHC is currently probing physics on the scale of ~ 10^4 GeV so we're not even close to probing things in the realm of quantum gravity.

Note that this analysis has nothing to do with string theory at all and generalizes to any theory of quantum gravity.