What I like to do is advertise for Python and .NET skills. That weeds a lot of bad ones out.
As far as bad devs go, don't they exist for most platforms? I mean, is every Ruby programmer a genius?
That said, I don't think it's fair to hold the same opinion of ASP.NET MVC developers - as it's essentially the same level of abstraction as Rails.
Knowing how webforms tried to warp how the web actually works was truly annoying. I understand why they did it, but it really does not help a web programmer in the long run.
And if .NET 4.0 didn't allow you to use ClientIDMode to set your own element IDs I'd have lost it entirely.
After they're hired at a bigcorp, the devs get by through cargo-culting and leaning on the GUI, so they never learn to actually program. Visual Studio is a great IDE, but it's too helpful for the beginning programmer. 5-10 years later, they've got enough "programming experience" on their resumes to get hired as "senior" devs.
Yes, they are geniuses, because of this: http://www.paulgraham.com/pypar.html
If you want a comparatively esoteric language today, try ML or Haskell.
[0] In this context, a "PHP programmer" is not simply a programmer who uses PHP, but a programmer who uses only PHP and is almost certainly clueless about CS fundamentals.
That being said, the new generation of ASP.NET MVC devs is top notch. People like Scott Hanselman and Phill Haack have helped make some vast improvements in the stack.
Our company is part of an early adopter program which is the reason they invited us to Redmond. We got to meet the Azure teams and really drill them with questions. I came back with a better appreciation for what they're trying to pull off. It feels like they're trying to build an race car and drive it at the same time. Microsoft wants to be attractive to the corporate world and smaller businesses at the same time. That's though.
The documentation isn't fantastic but I blame it on the speed that they are moving. Luckily there are some pretty smart and available developers that contribute to the community. Guys like Steve Marx (http://blog.smarx.com) and Wade Wegner (http://www.wadewegner.com) really know their stuff. I met them on my last visit. We've actually been invited up for another round of Azure 'sneak peeks' in June.
We love the framework. But its definitely not the only stack we use. I also agree that there are bad .Net developers that spoil it for the rest of us. In my opinion, most of the issues seem to be associated with ASP.Net and claiming to be a web developer without understanding how the web actually works. Many of them are so into just using the tools that they never bother to learn Javascript and instead insist on doing Postbacks for everything.
I feel that we're starting to see a new side of Microsoft when it comes to the web and startups.
Things like ASP.Net MVC, Azure and BizSpark give me hope.