News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cider 1.0 by gtvwill on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:03PM (#25574979)
Dear whoever deals with this in i.t. next time you come up with a company or product and name it some pre existing object but now it's a service. Stop. It's a terrible decision. Go back to the drawing board. Short flick through this and I see both cider and slime and neither have any correlation to what the words mean. It's a royal pita that tech has gone this way.

Can anyone actually explain why this naming method has grown in popularity?

Re:Cider 1.0 by nimih on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:44PM (#25575419)
Yeah, they should've gone with more descriptive names such as "The Clojure Interactive Development Environment" and "The Lisp Interaction Mode for Emacs". It's too bad they didn't.

On a wholly unrelated note, it is certainly strange that in all their documentation, SLIME and CIDER are stylized as all-caps for some reason; I wish I could figure out why...

Re:Cider 1.0 by gtvwill on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @05:31PM (#25575865)
I honestly find it difficult to keep track of these names and their double meanings. It doesn't come across instantly as an acronym it just looks like a company name being yelled.

If it were an acronym I'd expect full stops between each letter. I find the long names far more descriptive and useful I can read that and go yep...topic has no interest to me. CIDER doesn't have the same effect. This ain't just this app that's done it. Another app I had a similar mental struggle associating was slack. Literally can't get into my head what the term slack has to do with a messaging app.its been too long associated in my head as a negative term for being lazy.

I come from a work history in construction. Things are called what they are and namings generally pretty basic. I don't find dealing with the naming in tech anywhere near as easy. It's a bit of a barrier to learning for me tbh.

Re:Cider 1.0 by nimih on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @07:29PM (#25576871)
Truth be told, I share your frustration in general with tech naming, especially with enterprise tools and web development tools, but I do think that acronyms and initialisms--when the expansion is descriptive and accurate (a non-example being LAME, for instance)--are a reasonable compromise between "call something what it is" (which CIDER and SLIME both do, modulo an extra snarky word or two) and "avoid having a name which is 25 characters long".
Re:Cider 1.0 by b3n on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:09PM (#25575043)
To be fair, they are named SLIME and CIDER, not "slime" and "cider", as they are both acronyms.
Re:Cider 1.0 by agambrahma on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:39PM (#25585811)
Wha ... it's in keeping with a rich tradition of project names going back decades.

"Gone this way"? Lol.

Re:Cider 1.0 by agambrahma on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:42PM (#25585854)
Although I _do_ see your point, in that you'd have different expectations from something you'd like to sell to stakeholders in a company ... I guess Cider is self-consciously _outside_ that genre.

The feature/bug here is having a very wide spectrum of stuff that people work on, and some of it is simply always going to be non-mainstream by choice/intent.

Re:Cider 1.0 by albatruss on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:28PM (#25575271)
What do you mean "that tech has gone this way"? Since SLIME was written, in 2003?