Re:Raytracing won't simplify AAA real-time rendering
by lmm on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:46PM
(#25565726)
> What does raytracing have to do with the popularity of custom engines?
Raytracing is being used as a synecdoche for technological advances in rendering. The point is that as off-the-shelf rendering improves, the advantages of a vertically integrated engine diminish.
> Off topic, but this is not a good analogy. The "cloud" is just a network of mainframes, which means mainframes are arguably the dominant form of computing (and will become more dominant as thin clients, like Stadia, rise in popularity).
> Mainframes were not necessarily purpose-built, unique machines. They were instead defined by their sharing model, which is where the term "personal computing" comes from -- as a contrast to the mainframe/server model.
That's a very essentialist perspective; there are a lot of ways mainframe computing differs from typical personal computing and no single one of them is definitive. As a programmer, a mainframe offered you a reliable computing environment, because they're built to be highly available from the hardware up. That's very much not the case with the cloud, which follows a worse-is-better approach where your jobs can be terminated whenever and you're expected to handle it. While shared computing resources may be making a comeback, I don't think that kind of ground-up high availability will, so while the cloud has some aspects in common with mainframes, it's very much not the same thing.
Raytracing is being used as a synecdoche for technological advances in rendering. The point is that as off-the-shelf rendering improves, the advantages of a vertically integrated engine diminish.
> Off topic, but this is not a good analogy. The "cloud" is just a network of mainframes, which means mainframes are arguably the dominant form of computing (and will become more dominant as thin clients, like Stadia, rise in popularity).
> Mainframes were not necessarily purpose-built, unique machines. They were instead defined by their sharing model, which is where the term "personal computing" comes from -- as a contrast to the mainframe/server model.
That's a very essentialist perspective; there are a lot of ways mainframe computing differs from typical personal computing and no single one of them is definitive. As a programmer, a mainframe offered you a reliable computing environment, because they're built to be highly available from the hardware up. That's very much not the case with the cloud, which follows a worse-is-better approach where your jobs can be terminated whenever and you're expected to handle it. While shared computing resources may be making a comeback, I don't think that kind of ground-up high availability will, so while the cloud has some aspects in common with mainframes, it's very much not the same thing.