News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:He spent 10 days in jail after facial recognition led to ... by digdigdag on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:28PM (#25562863)
It's illegal. Prior authorization _should_ be required using someone's copyrighted work . In this case, the AI firm that compiled the profile of this poor soul probably had not reached out and asked for authorization for use of his image in a vast database which is then productized and sold to law enforcement agencies.

Now, things get complicated when you involve firms which, in the process of signing up a user, might force an agreement to sell/market the data in a non-exclusive manner to "trusted partners". Sooooo...is it illegal? Depends on on the lawyer and how long you can fund a lawsuit for, I suppose.

Re:He spent 10 days in jail after facial recognition led to ... by ve55 on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:11PM (#25563850)
We do not actually have precedence of this being illegal yet. You are not using the image in creation of a work (in which case, you need permission), but using it to train an AI model, which we currently have no legal indication is not allowed, even if the image is copyrighted.
Re:He spent 10 days in jail after facial recognition led to ... by YawningAngel on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:01PM (#25565371)
Could you explain to me why you don't consider Clearwater's product to be a work in this regard? It seems plausible to me that someone could infringe copyright by incorporating copyrighted works into a machine learning model
Re:He spent 10 days in jail after facial recognition led to ... by ve55 on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @01:40PM (#25573192)
I don't have much of an opinion myself on it, I'm just trying to state that so far, this appears to be the status quo. Here is some recent additional information on it compiled by Gwern: https://www.gwern.net/Faces#copyright (scroll up just above this link):

>Mod­els in gen­eral are gen­er­ally con­sid­ered “trans­for­ma­tive works” and the copy­right own­ers of what­ever data the model was trained on have no copy­right on the mod­el. (The fact that the datasets or in­puts are copy­righted is ir­rel­e­vant, as train­ing on them is uni­ver­sally con­sid­ered fair use and trans­for­ma­tive, sim­i­lar to artists or search en­gi­nes; see the fur­ther read­ing.) The model is copy­righted to whomever cre­ated it.