News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by klipt on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:03PM (#25561415)
I think SF has already taken the hint that they can outsource their residents to Oakland.

Residents strain the city budget via things like public schools. Businesses put money into the city budget via gross receipts taxes.

SF wants the businesses but is very happy for residents to live elsewhere.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by lumost on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:07PM (#25561440)
CT went this way as well, eventually the businesses look to follow residents - particularly younger residents who can't afford the inflated rent or down payments.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by lotsofpulp on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:15PM (#25561510)
CT has a different problem, they kicked the labor expenses 30 to 50 years into the future via underfunded defined benefit pension benefit, retiree healthcare, and other deferred compensation.

They don’t have a tier 1 city which people are willing to pay a premium to live in, and the taxpayers today are balking at paying for labor performed decades ago.

I’d be wary of starting a business subject to a relatively deeply indebted government if I had other options.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by gen220 on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:37PM (#25561776)
Can you expand on this?

Did CT follow Oakland, where SF is NYC? Or if CT is SF, where is the corresponding Oakland?

I live in NYC, and my view of CT is that its modern identity is dominated by being a suburb to NYC, with a handful of big and old businesses in the big cities to keep domestic economy afloat.

The places in my mind that don't fit this model are all east of New Haven, at which point CT starts to be "Coastal New England", a region that, excepting Boston, continues up to Bar Harbor, ME.

But my view is obviously biased by my limited experience, I'm curious to hear more of your perspective.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by lumost on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:30PM (#25562879)
During the suburban expansion of the last century many southern CT towns allowed in businesses but declined to expand housing and transit availability. This combined with strong NIMBYism drove up housing prices in southern CT.

A good modern analogue of southern CT from the 70s-90s would be the valley in the bay area e.g. Palo Alto, Mountain View etc.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by throwawaybbqed on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:03PM (#25564341)
Not disagreeing with you but some additional points:

I don't think CT's housing issues are anywhere remotely as bad as the Bay area. Stamford is the tier 1 city in CT IMHO, which seemed kind of lame. i.e. we would have friends in places further east (almost as far as New Haven) who would come to Stamford for the "scene". I use quotes because the scene in Stamford was pretty muted. We (who lived in Stamford) would drive to Manhattan for our weekends and special weeknights. I thought it worked really well for us. For 2400 a month, we were living in Luxury apartments and life was car friendly. Housing didn't seem too overpriced (starter homes were 600K IIRC). IMO, Stamford was pretty neat a few years back .. not sure if it has changed.

Bay area housing just went stupid until the pandemic hit. I moved out and so did many people I know. It was just not "affordable" on a 200K salary if you have multiple kids and a stay at home spouse. The housing you could get for $2400 was terrible in most parts that were reasonable commuting distance. I also would take metro north over caltrain any day.

Taxes are bad in both places. Stamford seemed more affordable and a lot better culture to me. I love the Bay area but can't make the math work :(

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by gota on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:23PM (#25563380)
What is CT? Pardon my ignorance
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by chub500 on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:37PM (#25563517)
Connecticut
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by onecommentman on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:38PM (#25563533)
Connecticut (CT)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._state_and_territo...

You can’t follow the game if you don’t have a program.

And it’s even an ANSI standard...

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by DoofusOfDeath on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:10PM (#25564416)
I grew up in southeastern CT and visit there occasionally. It's hard to describe how dead it is for commercial software development, even compared to Boston.

Even if one was inclined to open a good software shop in CT, you'd have neither low property prices nor an existing pool of highly skilled labor.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by jeffe on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @01:32AM (#25567341)
doesn't Greenwich have a good amount of quant shops?
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by DoofusOfDeath on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @02:17PM (#25573620)
I'm not sure, but that's an excellent counterpoint if so.

I shouldn't have presumed to speak for the parts of CT near NYC.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by lumost on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @05:47PM (#25576011)
Westport is home to Bridgewater capital, and Fairfield was until recently home to GE headquarters ( which also used to mean a lot more ).

I haven't lived in the area for some time, but I haven't heard of many new businesses form in the last ~20 years.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by lostdog on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:00PM (#25562621)
Anecdotally, I definitely came across more startups being located in the East Bay during my last job search. The founders already lived there, so they located the company there too.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by zapita on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:16PM (#25561518)
This is true, and will remain true until prop 13 is repealed.

The same dynamic is at play between San Jose and Mountain View/Cupertino/Palo Alto.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by fortran77 on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:21PM (#25562272)
What does Prop 13 have to do with the fact that they're not building enough housing?
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by epistasis on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:45PM (#25562497)
Prop 13 gives huge tax benefits to using land less than productively. Both selling land, and building on it will massively increase taxes.

Property values are rising at 5%-10% per year, but bulidings themselves only depreciate without dumping more money into the building. So that 5%-10% is all land value gain. As a property owner, why increase taxes by using the land more productively with new buildings, when you can continue to profit just as much without that? Also, attempting to build is hugely risky, because the permitting process is fraught, long, and likely to fail.

If we didn't have Prop 13, every single property owner would have a lot more incentive to actually try to build.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by smegger001 on Monday December 28, 2020 @10:55PM (#25566552)
> As a property owner, why increase taxes by using the land more productively with new buildings, when you can continue to profit just as much without that?

because the bubble will pop eventually.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by epistasis on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @01:06AM (#25567207)
Is it really a bubble if the overvaluation is created by law? The only way to pop the bubble would be to change the laws. And with Prop 13 being untouchable politically, and homeowners have an iron grip over city councils to keep cities underzoned, there's little chance of the systematic problem being eliminated any time soon.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by zapita on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:46PM (#25562501)
Here’s what I replied to:

> Residents strain the city budget via things like public schools. Businesses put money into the city budget via gross receipts taxes.

Prop 13 was meant to drastically cap property taxes. It was very successful in doing so. As a result, tax revenue from property taxes has also been capped dramatically, and cities adapted by relying more heavily on taxing businesses. Hence the current situation where residents cost more in services than they bring in in property taxes, incentivizing cities to attract businesses and wiggle out of their responsibility to build more housing units.

A good illustration of this dynamic is “RHNA” process for allocating housing unit quotas to each city in California. it is a very conflictual process where city councils typically fight tooth and nail to get their quotas reduced. A recent example in Palo Alto: https://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2020/11/18/palo-alto-ass...

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by pound on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:32PM (#25562377)
not enough housing to meet demand means raising property values, which is beneficial for property owners without having to pay more taxes
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by fortran77 on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:35PM (#25562403)
I don't think every California home owner is some evil beast trying to keep others out. I support building more homes, and would love it if every single family detached home were automatically rezoned for two units on the parcel. But if it weren't for Prop 13, my home and my business would have been forced out by people moving in and paying too much money for homes next door to me.

And "raising property values" only raises my property tax, while giving me no real benefit.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by epistasis on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:02PM (#25563169)
Prop 13 causers real estate values to rise much faster than they would have otherwise , by restricting the productive use of the land. It incentivizes land owners to not build and to not transfer land to someone who could make better use of it.

When it's a broad, general effect that covers an entire stateC that causes prices to rise much faster than they would have risen without Prop 13.

Prop 13 is one of the major causes of people "paying too much money," whatever that means. No purchaser wants to pay too much. The seller is the one setting the price when it is high, and Prop 13's incentives for speculation are what gives sellers so much market power to extort purchasers.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by sagarm on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:06PM (#25564930)
By "forced out" you mean you could

1) sell, reaping a huge windfall. 2) use a HELOC or reverse mortgage to pay for the higher property taxes.

But of course you'd prefer both to keep the windfall and not move, a privilege afforded to you by prop 13. That is only natural.

Meanwhile, homelessness in the state continues to rise as high land values make housing production and anti-growth activists on planning committees exacerbate our housing shortage.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by watwut on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:57AM (#25568329)
I find it acceptable that people want to stay at home where their social networks and memories are. You all act like it is OK to push people out from their homes, just because you have money and want that place.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by zapita on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @05:54PM (#25576072)
I agree it would not be OK for people to be forced to leave their home because they cannot afford to pay their property tax.

But there are simple solutions to this problem which do not create even worse problems, unlike prop 13. For example, Texas allows taxpayers 65 years of age or older to defer their property tax payments. In other words, the tax is still due, but not until the property is sold.

Why did California voters not implement this much simpler approach to preventing displacement? Because the goal was never to prevent displacement - it was to lock in massive tax subsidies for established homeowners, at the expense of everyone else.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by sagarm on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:17AM (#25579703)
California already has a means-tested tax deferral program.

https://sco.ca.gov/ardtax_prop_tax_postponement.html

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by sagarm on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:43PM (#25583825)
If they are truly unable to pay, California already has a means tested tax postponement program:

https://sco.ca.gov/ardtax_prop_tax_postponement.html

reply

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by KptMarchewa on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @12:46PM (#25572436)
It's acceptable to force them out if they don't want to pay for the privilege.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by zapita on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:51PM (#25562542)
> But if it weren't for Prop 13, my home and my business would have been forced out by people moving in and paying too much money for homes next door to me.

Prop 13 does not solve this problem. It merely shields historical homeowners from it, while amplifying it for everyone else. Many people and businesses were forced out by speculation because of prop 13, but you and a small group of people were exempted so you don’t care.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by fortran77 on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:56PM (#25562592)
How dare you say "I don't care." Who are you to speculate about what I think about?
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by epistasis on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:08PM (#25563240)
People are forced out of their home all the time, without the gigantic windfall of money that a property sale entails.

Evictions happen all the time, and these poor folks do not get the windfall of a $1M investment paying out. They get the trouble of trying to find a place to rent with an eviction on their record, which means they will be paying higher rents with less ability to pay.

Nobody should be forced from their home, homeowner or renter. But in California we only privilege the already privileged with that sympathy.

Prop 13 has forced far more people out of their home than property taxes have forced people in NY State out of their home. And NY has high property taxes and lots of people. So does NJ.

The idea that Prop 13 protects people from being taxed out of their hugely inflating financial asset is somewhat preposterous on its face. It mostly protects large landholders, and gives a tiny tiny benefit to the people that we are concerned about.

Focusing on the ineffective application of protection to a tiny number of millionaire homeowners, while ignoring the wealth inequality that funnels money to the people with tens and hundreds of millions of property, is extremely short sighted. It's time to stop pretending that Prop 13 is about the minor side effect of protecting a homestead, and pay attention to its primary effects, which is to encourage financial speculation with land and to give away tons of tax subsidies to those with the most land wealth that are hoarding it the most from better uses.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by et-al on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:58PM (#25563727)
> The idea that Prop 13 protects people from being taxed out of their hugely inflating financial asset is somewhat preposterous on its face. It mostly protects large landholders, and gives a tiny tiny benefit to the people that we are concerned about.

When you say "large landholders", are you talking about REITs and commercial property holders? If so, wouldn't Prop 15 have addressed these issues?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_California_Proposition_15

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by epistasis on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:07PM (#25563804)
Anybody who owns more than a home, including "small" landlords.

If you look at land distribution in cities, you'll find lots of super wealthy families, hidden behind LLCs, and a few REITs, the smaller scale landlords, and then finally individual homeowners.

Those wealthy land hoarding families are often worse than REITs for cities, in that maintaining their own political power is more important than profits, and that can be worse for people on the lower end not the economic scale than even REITs' horrifying landlord behaviors.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by et-al on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:52PM (#25564231)
Thanks. I had briefly thought "what if we just tax second homes at market rate?" But quickly realized the loophole of creating a company/trust per property.

Have you come across any good articles showing the breakdown of land ownership in SF?

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by watwut on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:59AM (#25568343)
"You should be thankful for having to move despite really not wanting to, because some other people have been completely screwed" is an abusive logic tho.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by epistasis on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @10:41AM (#25582575)
It is abusive logic, but it's nothing like anything I said or what I read from other people.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by fortran77 on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:42PM (#25566152)
Nobody's getting forced out of "their" home -- unless they can no longer afford to pay the taxes.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by kelnos on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:50PM (#25564793)
I think the point being made is that if you support Prop 13, you either a) are wildly misinformed about its effects, or b) don't care about its effects because you are in the privileged group that benefits from it at the expense of others.

(Whether or not the assumptions behind this assumption are true is of course up for debate, though I personally tend to believe Prop 13 is a bad deal, even for those who think they benefit from it.)

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by zapita on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:39PM (#25562973)
Perhaps you simply were not aware of the fact that prop 13 contributes to the displacement of people and businesses you claim to care about. I that case, it is now up to you to act on this newly acquired information and revisit your support of prop 13. The choice is yours.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by phenkdo on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:48PM (#25564199)
I thought "there is no shortage if you pay enough" shibboleth is universally applicable. H1b/housing/healthcare ?
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by klipt on Monday December 28, 2020 @10:30PM (#25566438)
Actually no, land is the one thing you can't make more of, which is why economists say a land value tax is one of the most efficient taxes (since supply is fixed, taxes can't reduce supply).

It's true you can make more housing by building up, but only if city zoning allows, which NIMBYs don't want.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by random314 on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:07PM (#25562683)
Are you in favor of a wealth tax in general, or only property taxes?
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by Kalium on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:09PM (#25562700)
Wealth taxes in general are challenging to execute. Property taxes are much easier, as well as deal with the extra issues brought on by land ownership that cash-equivalent wealth does not.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by Tiktaalik on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:13PM (#25563869)
A property tax is a type of wealth tax.

A wealth tax is no more difficult to execute than our existing property tax system.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by Kalium on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:20PM (#25563939)
You're absolutely right - a property tax is a type of wealth tax. I completely agree, which is why I attempted to differentiate between a general-purpose tax on all wealth in any form and a tax on real property. Please accept my humble apologies for my failures to be less clear than I could have been - my communication skills are a work in progress.

With that said, I have been under the impression that countries that have attempted to levy general-purposes taxes on all forms of wealth have in many cases run into practical difficulties. This requires things like finding a fair way to value and re-value an art collection or shares in a company not traded or liquid. In several cases - like France - these difficulties and others have led to dropping general-purpose wealth taxes.

Have I been laboring under a misapprehension? Can you help me understand what I've missed?

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by Tiktaalik on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:39PM (#25564105)
I don't think you're wrong. There's easy parts (ie. publicly traded equities) and hard parts (eg. art collections).

I've been skeptical of skepticism (lol) of the wealth tax mostly because the easy parts dominate the hard parts. Most wealth is in the easily identifiable areas (ie. equities and property) not the hard areas. Even with private companies like some startup, surely the shares have some known valuation right?

My point is though that we've already built a bureaucratic apparatus to evaluate wealth in our property assessment system so surely it's possible to extend this.

A possible implementation would be to mostly ignore the "hard" sectors of wealth (eg. car collections/art collections) or do random audits of the tricky parts just to keep people honest.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by kelnos on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:47PM (#25564757)
My -- perhaps overly cynical -- expectation is that a "focus on the easy stuff" wealth tax would just cause wealthy people to move their assets into the "hard stuff" as much as possible.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by Tiktaalik on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:35PM (#25565155)
Yeah that'd be my expectation as well.

I think the hope would be that there'd be would be some limit to the willingness for someone to shift money into relatively illiquid assets (ie. cars) that aren't really that good of investments instead of keeping their money in equities and simply pay the tax. There's a balance to find there in the policy.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by Kalium on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:44PM (#25564151)
Do you think it's perhaps worth looking at places that have tried wealth taxes? I think it possible that there might be some lessons to be learned from the well-intentioned and sincerely tried efforts of others. Perhaps our basic assumption that what works for real property will surely work for everything might not be trivially true, for example.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by Tiktaalik on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:32PM (#25565122)
Yeah sure, but we should also be aware that the wealthy do not want these taxes, and will use every means to ensure they are not enacted. This includes spreading FUD about their implementation and results.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by Kalium on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:37PM (#25565164)
I, personally, hesitate to characterize the lived experiences with policy choices of other polities as FUD. I understand that this is a deeply personal choice, and as such some might differ.
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by Tiktaalik on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:00PM (#25565359)
I'm speaking mostly to the media (owned by whom?), politicians and the surrogates of wealth that appear as a talking head to speak about the wealth tax.

The "Taxes were repealed in Europe so case closed" message that wealth is all too happy to push is a deflection from a thorough examination of the policy. Why were these policies "failures" in Europe? Some of the flaws of the European taxes have been already directly addressed by more recent Bernie and Warren proposals. For another example the issue some European countries had of their wealthy fleeing the country to avoid the tax isn't even possible US's tax system which will tax you regardless of where you live.

Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by satellite2 on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:13PM (#25564448)
You could use (sic) instead of (lol)
Re:Average Rent in San Francisco Has Dropped $1k This Year by aegis4244 on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:50PM (#25566211)
Setting a value is easy. Let the asset holder owing the tax set the value. Should the IRS disagree, let the IRS purchase the asset.