Re:Noise-canceling headphones without the headphone
by marcan_42 on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:41AM
(#25557936)
It's a soundfield problem. This only works for wavelengths that are larger than the size of the emitters and the distance between them. And even then it only works well if you can get the emission pattern of your cancelling speaker exactly the same as the source.
So, assuming you had a magical beamforming speaker array around your circular saw, you'd still only be able to cancel frequencies around under 1kHz, because there's no way to get the thing in phase above that.
This is why noise-canceling earphones have much better active cancellation at high frequencies than headphones, which rely more on passive isolation until lower frequencies. They're smaller.
Re:Noise-canceling headphones without the headphone
by gocartStatue on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:59AM
(#25557766)
theoretically, if the saw has constant RPM then just playing back inverted recording loudly would do it. You just need to match them in phase :)
I've been using ANC headphones since I started woodworking in the garage and it works for me but not for my neighbours. Soundproofing the garage is difficult and not always possible (not when the door is open anyway), so I would pay top dollar for something like this.