Re:San Francisco Set to Ban Unsolicited Phone Books
by tzs on Tuesday May 17, 2011 @01:19AM
(#2555370)
Seattle has already done this, except in Seattle it is an opt-out list, similar to the "do not call" list.
There was a story about this on NPR today, and they compared Seattle's approach to San Francisco's. The SF approach is drawing a lot of opposition from advocates and aid groups from the poor and the elderly. The fear is that there are a lot of people who do not use online directories and depend on their phone books to look up numbers.
In general, when you have some service that at one point nearly everyone depends on, and then as time passes many people start needing less and less, it seems to me to make the most sense to switch it to an opt-out service for existing people so that you don't disrupt those who still depend on it, and make it opt-in for new people.
There was a story about this on NPR today, and they compared Seattle's approach to San Francisco's. The SF approach is drawing a lot of opposition from advocates and aid groups from the poor and the elderly. The fear is that there are a lot of people who do not use online directories and depend on their phone books to look up numbers.
In general, when you have some service that at one point nearly everyone depends on, and then as time passes many people start needing less and less, it seems to me to make the most sense to switch it to an opt-out service for existing people so that you don't disrupt those who still depend on it, and make it opt-in for new people.