It depends what you mean by “free will” — the phrase “free will” is as ill-defined as “common sense” and “consciousness”.
I take the view that ∀ x ∈ <free will definitions>, Has(x, humans) ≡ Has(x, AI)
I agree with your claim. I also believe many to see “free will”/consciousness/etc as that certain je ne sais quoi that separates the human experience from that of computers:
∀ x ∈ <free will definitions>, Has(x, humans) ≡ ~Has(x, AI)
For these to both be true, <free will definitions> becomes empty. Thus I argue we have none. Edit, or rather it’s meaningless to argue if we have any or not, as it cannot be defined.
> or rather it’s meaningless to argue if we have any or not, as it cannot be defined.
This sums up my view too. Can't argue about it if you can't define it.
Yes, that also fits my observations of such arguments.
Free will is a cultural concept, not a biological one. Consciousness may be driven by a biological machine, but development of our ego is influenced a lot by culture.
Free will is faith in the sense that we learn the concept from our culture as our sense of self develops. The assumption of having it shapes our thinking such that we can say we actually have it.
A person who took their inner voice as voice from the gods would have a restricted free will in this view.
Thus “free will” must come from some sort of faith. Either it was given to us by “God”, or we’re all part of some simulation and it exists on a level we don’t know about, or something else entirely too advanced for us to understand.