It seems to me that lots of people have endless energy for this fight, unfortunately.
I can see being defensive about the importance of one's discipline in a society that sometimes seems to deemphasise it, but you'd think that struggle would make one more, not less, sympathetic to the need to keep basic literacy in other disciplines.
It’s a shame, too. As an undergraduate I had a very small amount of exposure to some papers in theoretical computer science. I presume they were fairly typical for the world of mathematics - trying to establish boundaries on how small something can be. And not much application in the real world. But I remember having my mind blown at the way the authors could take one problem, convert it to some completely different domain, and use previous work in that domain to prove things about the original problem. It was very beautiful, and I think even that very limited exposure has changed the way I see the world.
Then the real world came knocking and I haven’t been back since.
Most of college was proving everything.
Okay, I get this is important for high level math.
I want to do “something” with it.
I did a lot of basic robotics programming for pay in early college. Taught myself a lot of math to get the job done. Later I hit Trigonometry. Wow that would have been handy in that role.
I agree with your post, except that statement is a bit of personal choice. From my perspective, knowing how airplanes work and how they fly makes my life richer, but I doubt lit majors would feel the same way.
(For example, when my house was built, I noticed a weak spot in the structure holding the house up, and had it reinforced. Without engineering training, I never would have noticed. Does this matter? In my previous house, some of the doors wouldn't close properly, and in the crawl space I noticed the main loads were not supported directly by a column on a concrete pad. The structure there had been gradually sinking. Jacking up that section of the house, installing a pad and a column, fixed that and the doors all worked again. I missed another structural fault until one day a window just shattered from the stress of the distorting wall.)
So here’s what I should think is the obvious answer: No, significant formal or informal maths training is neither necessary nor sufficient for a successful or even exemplary career as a programmer. But talent and success in the two do seem to correlate pretty strongly, and those who do have above average backgrounds in maths seem to feel it’s beneficial and provides an advantage. No, you don’t need maths any more than you need strong writing skills or comfort teaching or experience with office politics or a sophisticated sense of humour. Those are all, however, astonishingly useful in getting the things you want, even if that’s only a richer experience of life.