News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aliens Likely Annihilated Themselves Through Progress by gus_massa on Friday December 25, 2020 @11:53AM (#25537503)
This is based in a preprint in the arXiv. Until peer review and published in a serious journal, it is no more relievable than a blog post in random WordPress site like https://terrytao.wordpress.com/

They have a complex calculation for the formation of civilization, but I can't check it.

Then they make a model and for the calculatiosn they peak some values for the unknown parameters. They assume that self destruction rate per mega year is 0%, 50% or 99%. Unsurprisingly, after 1000 mega years most of the civilizations that appeared had collapsed.

Ignoring the 0% chance that is also unrealistic, with a 50% or 99% chance of dying, the civilizations would last at most a few mega years, so the surviving one are jut the one that appear just before the simulation ended.

The main problem is that nobody know if P_{ann} is 99% or 50% like they choose, or other number like 1% or 0.001%. In a simulation with a 0.001% most of the civilizations would have been alive at the end.

Re:Aliens Likely Annihilated Themselves Through Progress by f6v on Friday December 25, 2020 @12:02PM (#25537554)
I wonder if we can ever build a model for estimating survival of advanced civilization. I mean, can an ant make inferences about humans?