Isn’t your job to make sure security measures don’t suck, aren’t less efficient, and don’t cause headaches?
This seems to be a very defeatist attitude to take.
From my personal experience one of the following happens when a security team takes your perspective: 1.) users work around security mitigations, causing worse security issues 2.) workers quit the company due to friction when working 3.) the security manager gets fired because they won’t ever compromise
You seem oblivious to the fact that you can still be effective but not a shitty security team.
Your way of approaching this literally makes people who should listen to you and trust you want to do the opposite. What an awful security team you’re part of.
It's funny you say that my way of working literally makes people want to do the opposite of trust me, when I send them a phishing e-mail that's exactly what I'm aiming for ;P
I've also worked at a place where the security team were trusted collaborators. Devs were comfortable communicating with them. Their security skills improved over time, and so did the security of the software they wrote.
The latter strategy is far more effective at moving the needle over the long term.
Treat. People. Decently.
I said shitty. No other swearing and no name calling. What exactly are you reading?
The real thing happened, was detected and shut down. Then they did some trainings over the course of a year, and had us test the same thing again next year. Results were not particularly good, and people got upset that they did not receive the promised Christmas gifts.
Afaict, these trainings stop being effective at around 10%. That is, 10% of all people being phished like this will do everything you tell them to. Up to and including sending your their password and installing malware on their machines following your e-mail instructions.
I also prefer my security measures procedural, technical and layered. Like I said before, phishing simulations don't really work for me at all... Currently many places where I do some work the security department have a large say in what happens, regardless of goodwill. Security measures always suck, are less efficient and cause no end of headaches, you mostly have 0 goodwill anyway.