There are more humane ways to train an army than to make them think of situations where someone is trying to kill them, but... if that comes at the expense of worse training (and therefore actual higher likelihood of death) then it doesn't do anyone favors.
The fact that so many people fell for this test means there's something (obviously!) around this scenario that makes it particularly sensitive and mistake-prone for people. Your IT department may chose to avoid it, but people trying to phish you, won't.
You don’t train your employees on active shooter drills by having a guy barge in shooting blanks.
Source: was in the army.
I was leaving a hotel near the airport in Delhi, and as were waiting outside for an Uber the manager of the hotel told us not to be alarmed if we saw some guys with guns running towards the hotel. Told us the police were running a terrorism scenario to see how the local hotels would react, and whether they would follow the plan for such an event. The guns would be unloaded, but everything else would seem realistic. The manager and the outside security knew about it (because they had to let the “terrorists” into the hotel) but no other staff or guests had been warned. We were only told because we were outside and might see them coming and he didn’t want us to give the game away.
Fortunately our Uber arrived before the “terrorists”. It’s possible the manager was just fucking with us, and none of it happened, but it didn’t seem like it and if he was that’s a pretty messed-up thing to do, too. It occurred to us that if they were actual terrorists he might be in cahoots and making sure they got into the building.
He also told us how in a real event he told his outside security guys to run away, they couldn’t stop terrorists anyway, and there was no point getting themselves killed.
The tradeoff here is an idiotic one.
You don't set your own building on fire in order to test fire safety.
You don't destroy company morale to test phishing security.
It's really that simple.
At some point you just say "look, we need to make sure our people are trained, if people think fire drills are stupid or upsetting, we have to take that hit because the alternative is worse."
You ain't comparing the same thing. Temporary discomfort is not the same as this boneheaded move that wrecked their morale.
It's trained them not to believe their company when they offer a bonus.
Which might stop the same email from working tomorrow, but not the one saying "This needs to be filled out by Friday!" or "Class action settlement against GoDaddy over fake bonuses"
You put people in unnecessary danger by putting them in an unpredictable situation. That is why training sessions are varied and thoroughly debriefed so that participants can know how what they learned in the current session can be applied at different settings.
Source, anecdotal: I’m a former life guard that had regular drills, and never entered one unknowingly.