News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: I'm building a Windows video editor, what are you... by meibo on Thursday December 24, 2020 @06:41AM (#25526699)
Have an UI mode that's optimized for casual users!

So many of my relatives ask me where Windows Movie Maker went - it wasn't the most powerful tool of course, but it was so easy to use and arrange videos with, especially for not too tech-literate people.

There's nothing that comes close, especially not what MS has built-in at the moment (basically just generating videos from slideshows with confusing UX).

Re:Ask HN: I'm building a Windows video editor, what are you... by Mayzie on Thursday December 24, 2020 @09:06AM (#25527518)
> Have an UI mode that's optimized for casual users!

Kdenlive[1] is very good for this and kind of resembles Windows Movie Maker of old. I'm not a movie editor, so Kdenlive is my goto clip editor when all I want to do is something simple without having to think how to do it (I've tried iMovie and Premiere). Very intuitive!

[1] https://kdenlive.org/en/

Open source, KDE, Qt-based project.

Re:Ask HN: I'm building a Windows video editor, what are you... by CinematicStudio on Sunday December 27, 2020 @02:53AM (#25549586)
I did take a look. It's a nice tool even though the UI is not the most modern :) Seems the features that it has have already been suggested by others in the thread. Having said that, since I installed it on my desktop, I will take another look at it later, and maybe draw a bit more inspiration :)

Thanks again!

Re:Ask HN: I'm building a Windows video editor, what are you... by CinematicStudio on Thursday December 24, 2020 @09:20AM (#25527638)
Thanks!

I wasn't aware of kdenlive, until a few days ago when it popped in my news feed :D I'll take a look :)

Re:Ask HN: I'm building a Windows video editor, what are you... by teleforce on Friday December 25, 2020 @04:10AM (#25535297)
This. Please optimize for casual users and due to Covid-19 social distancing more people are forced to making and editing their own video.

These are my two suggestions:

1)Try to enable targeted video size feature for the generated/exported video. Also design a simple UI menu to automatically transcode and resize the generated video according to the chosen video format.

2) Make it easy for the authoring of the sub-title by including dead simple and easy to use vector graphic editor built-in and integrated inside the video editor (not third party full blown vector editor).

Re:Ask HN: I'm building a Windows video editor, what are you... by CinematicStudio on Friday December 25, 2020 @04:24AM (#25535345)
Thanks!

> This. Please optimize for casual users and due to Covid-19 social distancing more people are forced to making and editing their own video.

Agreed! I've done my best to do just that - but clearly, you will be the judge of that :)

> 1)Try to enable targeted video size feature for the generated/exported video. Also design a simple UI menu to automatically transcode and resize the generated video according to the chosen video format.

Agreed! I would say I've done achieved this - basically, when you click 'Export', you can set the FPS, and the video format (low, HD, Full HD, 4k - coming soon).

There's also an option for video ratio (such as 16:9, 4:3, and so on) - available via the project's settings. Hopefully people won't think it's buried too deep in the settings menu :)

> 2) Make it easy for the authoring of the sub-title by including dead simple and easy to use vector graphic editor built-in and integrated inside the video editor (not third party full blown vector editor).

Added to my todo list. I want to do it similar to what Adobe has - which will be a bit of work :D But yeah, I'll have it ;)

Re:Ask HN: I'm building a Windows video editor, what are you... by CinematicStudio on Thursday December 24, 2020 @07:31AM (#25526952)
Thanks! I'll take another look at Windows Movie Maker, apparently :) I would say my app is quite friendly, but then again, I may be biased :)
Re:Ask HN: I'm building a Windows video editor, what are you... by omk on Thursday December 24, 2020 @07:37AM (#25526978)
Microsoft Photos App does provide a video editor now. Make sure you vet against its existing features.
Re:Ask HN: I'm building a Windows video editor, what are you... by CinematicStudio on Thursday December 24, 2020 @07:53AM (#25527038)
Thanks! I did check MS Photos app a while ago, and I've got pretty much all it has (and a lot more ;))

However, I added it to my todo list to take another look ;)