Re:Let the ultra-rich and influential skip the line for Covi...
by Pfhreak on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @02:13PM
(#25520966)
Ok, sure. In neither case is it basically a tax.
Also, philanthropy often gives you stuff. The WWF gives me a nice stuffed animal and thank you card, for instance. And plenty of wealthy donors mysteriously get their kids into colleges.
Re:Let the ultra-rich and influential skip the line for Covi...
by vorpalhex on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @02:19PM
(#25521043)
If you donate to the WWF, you can't demand they give you a stuffed animal and sue them if they fail to. Yes, you can respond to a gift with a gift - that doesn't make it a sale.
Taxes are taking wealth for government functions, whether it's against an individual, a company, etc. When you buy a pack of cigarettes (in the US) you're being taxed - the same goes for gasoline. Overcharging for the vaccine intentionally and using that to give out free vaccine doses is by definition a tax, in the same way that any consumption tax is a tax.
That the rich person receives the vaccine for their money, ie a material consideration, makes this not philanthrophy by definition - it's a sale. Or, put another way, me buying an overpriced handmade christmas ornament from Etsy isn't philanthropy either, even if I'm choosing to really overpay.