The initial argument was "we need IP law so we can enjoy big budget movies". The counterargument is "I don't care about those, here's a list of things I do care about that are made harder or threatened by IP law".

It's an interesting case in that the internet has caused big media to push for stricter copyright enforcement and experiment with giving people less and less rights on their products, but at the same time the internet has made people much more aware of the downsides of copyright.