News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by nabla9 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:12AM (#25507721)
Defence has to match the threat, no more.

Russia is the only threat. EU countries together outpace Russian military spending with large marging. Russia has no capability to act outside it's borders in high intensity warfare. Even limited involvement in Syria is wearing down their aircraft.

European defence has structural problem: scattering military resources all over the Europe. Spain, France and Belgium should keep most of their main battle tanks in Poland and send troops to train there. Russian amphibious attack from the North Atlantic is not a threat.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by kspacewalk2 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:34AM (#25508010)
All involvement of all military aircraft in any capacity wears them down. This is a tactic China is currently using to wear down Taiwan's aircraft[0].

Russia has tactical nuclear weapons to supplement their ability to act outside their borders in high intensity warfare.

Having a robust deterrent is the best way to prevent high intensity warfare in the first place.

[0] https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/hongkong...

>By increasing the tempo of these operations, the PLA can inflict disproportionate stress on Taiwan’s much smaller force. The Chinese military has more than 2,000 fighters, bombers and other warplanes, compared with Taiwan’s 400 fighters, according to the Pentagon’s annual report on Chinese military power, published in September. Over time, fuel costs, pilot fatigue and wear and tear on Taiwanese aircraft will threaten the readiness of the island’s air force if this pressure continues, according to Taiwanese and U.S. military analysts. The constant threat is also designed to exact a psychological toll on the defenders, they say.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by nabla9 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:42AM (#25508142)
Russia is declining power unlike China.

Russia struggles to maintain and repair their existing aircraft. Even increasing the rate of intercepts in the peacetime increases the attrition rate to unsustainable level.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by runarberg on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:57AM (#25508356)
> Having a robust deterrent is the best way to prevent high intensity warfare in the first place.

This is wrong. The best way to prevent warfare is to disarm the nations.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by Juliate on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:10PM (#25508525)
This feels wrong, but disarmement works when all parties willfully participate in it. All you need is one foul player for this path to fail.

Before WWII, Germany was forbidden from remaking an army. It still did. Where Europe & US could have played deterrence by forcing Germany to stop, they preferred to appease things. We all know what happened.

When you're in front of a bully, you might talk first and ask them once to turn it down. If that tactic doesn't work, disarmament is obedience.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by runarberg on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:19PM (#25511367)
> When you're in front of a bully...

I think it is a mistake to anthropomorphize nation states this way. Explaining international relations in terms of personal relations is misleading at best. A bully does not control a nuclear arsenal, nation states do.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:27PM (#25512104)
Given that Russia continues to behave as a bully (Georgia and Ukraine, at a minimum), I see exactly nothing wrong with calling them a bully.
Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by runarberg on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:27PM (#25512687)
That is fine, but problems arise when you start talking policy in an anthropomorphized context. Sure Russia is behaving like a bully, but that doesn’t mean the UK and other NATO members should call it’s parents and have Russia suspended from school.
Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @07:18PM (#25513015)
Obviously. But when people call Russia a bully, I rather doubt that they're anthropomorphizing them to that degree. And calling them a bully gives a convenient shorthand for both describing their behavior and stating that it's problematic.
Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by Someone on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:20AM (#25507823)
Does Belgium still have battle tanks? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_main_battle_tanks_by_c...:

“Belgium retired its last operational Leopard 1 MBTs in 2014. Some were kept in inventory for training and research purposes.”

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by baybal2 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:31AM (#25507971)
> EU countries together outpace Russian military spending with large marging.

And Russia gets 30 trained soldiers for the price of 1 NATO soldier

Feel the difference

> Russia has no capability to act outside it's borders in high intensity warfare

You are saying this about a country with the biggest tank armies anywhere in the world.

What you are saying is laughable to anybody with a dime of military education.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by bilbo0s on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:42AM (#25508138)
> Russia has no capability to act outside it's borders in high intensity warfare

What you are saying is laughable to anybody with a dime of military education.

I didn't laugh, but I did raise an eyebrow. I just kind of chalked it up to the lack of military officers who comment on HN.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by nabla9 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:04PM (#25508454)
> You are saying this about a country with the biggest tank armies anywhere in the world.

Russia has 12,000+ tanks only in paper. Russia has only few tank divisions in working condition and equipped. Rest is just Soviet era junk that has not moved in decades. The military modernization program has stalled.

Russia can defend itself just fine. What Russia can't do is to large scale warfare attacking others. Any mobilization in Russia that is not purely defensive in the nature would fail. Reservist would simply not show up to fight for Putin.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by baybal2 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:28PM (#25508766)
> Russia has 12,000+ tanks only in paper. Russia has only few tank divisions in working condition and equipped. Rest is just Soviet era junk that has not moved in decades. The military modernization program has stalled.

How many European countries have countries have even 1 tank division?

Russia may have 12,000 pieces of junk tanks + 40,300 of junk APCs, IFVs, ARVs, and engineering vehicles + double of all of that in reserve, salvage, and storage, but who else do you think have?

Russia's Achilles heel is low morale, and low number of highly trained specialist, especially pilots. Second, is its military logistics (which itself is bigger, and better than that of most NATO countries)

Latest tank modifications Russia ordered was not some rocket munition, but a drive by wire system for tanks, so one can drive a tank like driving a car, as Russia for decades had more pieces of military hardware than pilots for them.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by nabla9 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:46PM (#25512299)
Just comparing modern main battle tanks that can have a change of making difference in the battle.

Russia has: 550 T-90's total. 450 T-80's active, only 170 upgraded. Few thousand outdated tanks unworkable condition. Then maybe up to ~500 T-72B3 (somewhat modernized and in workable conditions). Rest is just junk not touched or upgraded for 30 years after Soviet Union collapsed.

Poland+Germany together have 500 Leopard 2's. France has 400 Leclercs. Britain 200 Challenger 2's. (I'm not counting old but modernized tanks Poland has).

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by baybal2 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @08:10PM (#25513354)
You don't use something like T-55 to fight modern tanks. T-55, while is near worthless in tank-on-tank warfare, is still a 100mm self-propelled gun, and armor that will withstand anything, but dedicated anti-tank weaponry.

Even from my dated high school military lessons from around 2004-2006, I know the official doctrine of Russian tank forces is to avoid tank on tank combat with equal, or superior tanks.

Anything more substantial than 3rd generation tanks will not be engaged with guns, but with few heavy ATGMs per target from 5+ kms away. All T-72 in Russian service can fire 120mm ATGMs, even T-55s are supposed to have some 100mm ATGMs for them.

A wide front-offensive will certainly decrease the efficiency of anti-tank weapons on the defending side, and let the majority of attacking force to pass.

Biggest anti-tank unit today is an attack helicopter, hence Russian zeal to develop things like Panzir SPAG.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by nabla9 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:13PM (#25513672)
Old Soviet tanks are useless against against modern army as you can see in Syria, Irak and elsewhere. They have limited used only in defensive warfare if they don't have to move. If they move, they are quickly destroyed.

Russia has no logistical capacity to move any of those weapons far beyond it's borders like it had in Soviet Era. They could do single assault with 50-70k troops 300 km from their borders but they could not rotate or supply them or provide enough air cover.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by baybal2 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:56PM (#25513909)
> Russia has no logistical capacity to move any of those weapons far beyond it's borders like it had in Soviet Era. They could do single assault with 50-70k troops 300 km from their borders but they could not rotate or supply them or provide enough air cover.

Unless they can build a staging ground at a leisure pace in an ally country. Not to say that it was building up its already significant military logistics.

Now, why do you think such a such a force needs even bigger logistics buildup, far exceeding defensive use scenario?

All past of your comments on military strategy give off so much of youthful maximalism. In conflict, always expect the worst past holistic comparison. All things that "could never happen" according to military analysts do eventually happen.

A saying is you never expect the enemy to attack where you expect him the most.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:14AM (#25507755)
> Russia has no capability to act outside it's borders in high intensity warfare

They are creating plenty of pain with low intensity tactics.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by khuey on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:26AM (#25507904)
The Russian strategy of low-grade asymmetric conflict with strategic assets like nuclear weapons and a real air force to deter any serious consequences works remarkably well.
Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by nabla9 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:26AM (#25507905)
Low intensity tactics can't be used in high intensity warfare.

If Russian green men cross into Poland, Poland is not responding with low intensity. They mobilize the whole country to fight to fight high intensity warfare until Russians are thrown out.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by pmoriarty on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:39AM (#25508089)
"Spain, France and Belgium should keep most of their main battle tanks in Poland and send troops to train there"

Would troops and tanks even be relevant in a conflict between the NATO and Russia in the age of nuclear weapons?

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by nabla9 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:55AM (#25508319)
Russia is not ideological world power like Soviet Union was. Russia is declining state with normal national interests, nothing more. For Russia to go to war they need to have way to win and gain something.

If Russia uses nuke against NATO, there would be no road back to normal until there is regime change or surrender. Russia completely isolated from the rest of the world would have famine in few years even if NATO would use only isolate Russian from the rest of the world. Even China would be forced to choose to trade between the West and rest of the Asia or Russia.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by baybal2 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:09PM (#25509238)
NATO being busy with even a starving Russia in coming few years, will mean a near certain move from China in the East.

For America, it's uncertain what's more bad, giving China East Asia, or Western Europe to Russia.

Russia with West Europe will still be the same starving Russia, with even more depleted stocks of military hardware.

China with complete reign in the region means them being few years from building a blue water navy, and transoceanic landing force.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by nradov on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:27PM (#25509451)
China will have an effective blue water navy in a few years regardless of whether or not they seize part of the Russian far east. US has no way to block such a move beyond some token sanctions. We certainly aren't going to defend the Russian border under any plausible scenario.
Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by baybal2 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:56PM (#25509766)
I mean China's move on US allies in the region, not Russia.

> China will have an effective blue water navy in a few years regardless

US having bases to at least blunt, and slow offensive staging by China in case of war will make all the difference vs. not having them at all.

Re:Sweden edges closer to NATO membership by medium_burrito on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:25PM (#25508731)
Russia is a minor threat, and is becoming less powerful by the day. When Putin leaves (thanks, Parkinsons), there might be some internal turmoil, but that probably won't lead them to invade Sweden. The major threat is the mass migration from ME and Africa that will overwhelm Europe.

One of the big reasons to put together a competent military and logistics operation is to help neighboring countries become more stable. Without stability and peace economic growth is tenuous.