Re:'Hot migrating' from SVN to mercurial, and why we choosed...
by alexandrul on Monday May 16, 2011 @07:48AM
(#2552248)
Given that both tools have their ups and downs, my reasons for picking TortoiseHg for Windows development are listed on SO: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/2550091/best-support-now-...
In particular, Rebase in TortoiseGit has an excellent user interface that takes Git's command line rebasing process and turns it into a user-friendly graphical equivalent. I've yet to find any equivalently pleasant user interfaces in TortoiseHG; pretty much all of TortoiseHG's user interfaces are tangled messes of dropdown menus and checkboxes that try to reproduce every mercurial configuration switch.
TortoiseGit is also faster and more stable than TortoiseHG. I'm not sure if this is because TortoiseHG is largely written in Python+QT, or just because TortoiseGit is more mature - I use TortoiseHG a lot at work when interacting with mercurial repositories, and it crashes frequently, but I've never had TortoiseGit crash or freeze on me.
There are also a lot of UX problems with TortoiseHG that seem to originate in the design of Mercurial, though, so this may come down to my personal taste.