Re:Nobody ever ported Doom to run on a Cray 1
by walrus01 on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:43PM
(#25499330)
I have also seen mention of this in spacecraft design discussion. The concept being that for things which are powered from a radioisotope thermoelectric generator, it's safe to treat the RAM as storage.
Because there's absolutely no scenario after launch, in which the constant trickle of wattage flow from the RTG to the onboard DC distribution buses and computers would ever be interrupted.
If the power from the RTG were to ever be cut off it would be a catastrophic mission failure anyways, entirely aside from the power to the onboard computing systems being interrupted.
Re:Nobody ever ported Doom to run on a Cray 1
by heavenlyblue on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:05AM
(#25505069)
> I have also seen mention of this in spacecraft design discussion. The concept being that for things which are powered from a radioisotope thermoelectric generator, it's safe to treat the RAM as storage.
I don't buy it. They specifically design these systems with duplication in nature in case RAM gets corrupted by radiation in space. So you can't treat it as storage, but for very different reasons.
Re:Nobody ever ported Doom to run on a Cray 1
by jandrese on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:50PM
(#25500644)
Presumably the OS would be in some nonvolatile medium and the SSD would only be used for stuff like storing sensor data anyway. In the event of corruption or a system restart you would lose all of your working data but could bootstrap the system again.
Re:Nobody ever ported Doom to run on a Cray 1
by ardy42 on Monday December 21, 2020 @07:50PM
(#25501636)
While it would make sense to have recovery routines in some nonvolatile memory to handle a system corruption use case, I'm not sure it if would be necessary for a system restart. IIRC, core-based systems had nonvolatile RAM, and I think at least some of them would continue to execute the same memory image after reset. I think the point of the GP was that one of these DRAM based recorders is basically nonvolatile for all intents in purposes in this application.
I'd imagine it would be practical to build and use something similar for a multi-million dollar supercomputer where cost is secondary to performance.