But an excitable person can learn. Or be directed into another role. How does one motivate a disinterested but competent person? I fear that motivation is a harder problem to solve than lack of talent.
and almost any technical job can become complex enough to be intellectually interesting, if you have the freedom to use tools to automate the boring bits. what kills is being forced to do tedious rote work because you are restricted in your process. working on a production line is boring; building a production line is fascinating. the line between the two is clear in factory, but not in software development.
"exciting" is for non-technical marketing people with an attention span of 2 seconds before they see the next shiny object. absorbing, empowering work hasn't got much to do with excitement. it's about expressing and developing something of your own. it doesn't have to be different, or exciting, or ground-breaking. it just has to be yours, to develop in the way you see fit, to meet the requirements you are given.
i didn't know this when i started; i imagine selling "exciting" work will get you people with little experience. but i'm wiser now.
The method of frequent firing as feedback is far from optimal and not even feasible in smaller organizations. That is the context in which I'm operating and thinking about this problem.
With respect to the particular element of confirmation bias referenced in the first sentence, and repeating the second, hiring based on interest is a method that will seek to truthfully answer the question, "is this person going to solve the problem we want to solve?" rather than effectively allowing an employer to avoid a costly mistake.
Your comments about product development are not addressing anything in the post and could be delivered to a wall with similar effect.