Re:Perl 5.14 released
by chuhnk on Sunday May 15, 2011 @04:15AM
(#2549584)
I would love to see benchmarks against ruby 1.9.2. Perl always had comparable speed to ruby 1.8.6 with lower memory consumption and cpu usage. Now hopefully it'll be equivalent to ruby 1.9.2.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Here are some quick, unsophisticated benchmarks of a "Hello World" test web server. I ran it in our dev server (Centos 5.3 i386). Ran with ab -t 30 a few times and chose the fastest of the batch.
Perl 5.14, Dancer 1.3040, HTTP::Server::PSGI:
Requests per second: 856.48 [#/sec] (mean)
Memory after tests: 11296 (VSZ) 7632 (RSS)
Ruby 1.9.2, Sinatra 1.2.6, WEBRick 1.3.1: Requests per second: 402.72 [#/sec] (mean)
Memory after tests: 20612 (VSZ) 10628 (RSS)
I know. This is not, by any means, serious language benchmarks (ie. Sinatra, WEBRick, Dancer are interfering), but they give me a rough idea of how things can perform side-by-side for a given setup.I'm also a fan of running quick string management tests to roughly benchmark interpreters at a given servers, since most of our codebase do a lot of string manip. Here's a 1MB mem alloc + cat test:
Ruby 1.9.2:
$ time ruby -e 'x=""; (1..999999).each { x << "a" }'
real 0m0.313s
user 0m0.277s
sys 0m0.026s
Perl 5.14: $ time perl -E '$x.="a" for 1..999999'
real 0m0.167s
user 0m0.139s
sys 0m0.020s
As I said, this is completely unscientific. There are much better ways of benchmarking languages out there.I'm not sure using time is an accurate measurement of the speed of looping here since there is the cost of starting up the interpreter, but fun nonetheless to see.
I don't think the problem is that "this is completely unscientific."
It just seems really silly ;-)
If you check (historically) the benchmarks on http://shootout.alioth.debian.org/ then:
* perl5 was always a 2-4 times faster than than ruby 1.8
* perl5 & ruby 1.9 are comparable usually swapping places on different "Which programming languages are fastest?" benchmarks
* When taking in above speed benchmarks, memory used & code-used then perl5 just nudges in front of ruby 1.9. See "Which programming language is best?"
How did you check (historically) ?
Not following you here, how can speed of one language be the same as another's, but "with lower cpu usage"?
Sorry I threw that into the same sentence when it made no sense to do so.
CPU does not necessarily have to be the bottleneck.