News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by mannykannot on Sunday December 20, 2020 @11:02AM (#25487139)
Not obscure, but an unlikely originator of a globally-significant processor architecture.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday December 20, 2020 @11:36AM (#25487434)
Why unlikely? The UK has always had a significant presence in CS, both theoretically and in practical engineering.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by vidarh on Sunday December 20, 2020 @02:30PM (#25488862)
Because there were multiple relative giants in the 80's and 90's that had their own processor designs. The competition was broad, and much of it from far more well funded companies.

For all of them to falter and ARM to succeed was a real long-shot.

Even well into the 90's, when several companies were looking at switching CPU architectures or supporting alternative architectures, ARM was just not on the radar for most developments, because people were looking to compete with x86 on performance.

People talked about the Alpha, MIPS, PPC, PA-RISC, not ARM. When ARM started appearing on the radar as more than a low end embedded option towards the end of the 90's, it was DEC's StrongARM family.

It was a very long way coming. Which makes it all the more impressive that they made it.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by mhh__ on Sunday December 20, 2020 @04:00PM (#25489450)
Isn't that mostly because all the RISC's either killed themselves or got killed, rather than ARM outcompeting as per se?

With the Alpha especially, it was a good architecture but (before my time, so I may be wrong) DEC seemed to have no idea how to actually sell it sustainably. Those companies probably would've been shocked at the idea of today's world where your average consumer can buy 20 billion transistor chip just to play games on and everyone owns about 10 other smaller processors (as opposed to a computer being a thing you either bought for your family, or a massive workstation that costs as much as a car)

Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by vidarh on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:22AM (#25496302)
Sort of, but the point is that ARM avoided that, while half a dozen companies with financial muscle allowing them to try and fail far more ended up failing outright or relegating themselves to niches.

ARM could have just as easily ended up making similar mistakes and died. That they didn't is pretty remarkable.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by rbanffy on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:36PM (#25500508)
The RISCs that survived are the ones that went where no x86 could go.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by rbanffy on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:21PM (#25500337)
> Isn't that mostly because all the RISC's either killed themselves or got killed

Every ecosystem where Windows was relevant ended consolidating on x86, because that was the platform that had best Windows support (Microsoft didn't even make their own software available on most of those).

POWER survived because it has its own ecosystem. Alpha was axed by Compaq, because Windows on Alpha sucked and they knew little else, PA was starved to death by HP with lack of investment, then buried by moving to Itanium (with the spectacular results we all know). SPARC wandered in the desert until Oracle acquired Sun and promptly bled it to death.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by factsonly on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:52PM (#25489395)
The main benefit of the ARM processor design was very high performance per watt which carved out a significant niche that then grew into a massive market
Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by rbanffy on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:24PM (#25500370)
In the beginning, it had great power characteristics, but it was also much faster than any x86.

That it evolved in the direction of power efficiency is more an effect of it being power efficient and being popular with embedded manufacturers, which created a feedback look that guided it to extreme power efficiency with reasonable performance, while x86 went the route of performance, power be damned.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by klelatti on Sunday December 20, 2020 @02:38PM (#25488922)
This is absolutely the key point.

They didn't try to compete on performance and didn't try to compete with Intel - both would have been losing strategies. Instead they competed on cost, power and on the ability to work better with other firms who didn't want to support their own architecture.

The comparison with MIPS I think is most interesting. MIPS could easily have taken the markets that Arm dominated but the strategy wasn't right.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by lsllc on Sunday December 20, 2020 @08:46PM (#25491331)
Don't forget ICL and the 2900 Series mainframes:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Computers_Limite...

Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by mannykannot on Sunday December 20, 2020 @12:22PM (#25487838)
I am not saying that the UK was an unlikely place for this to happen, but that it was unlikely that this particular company would do it.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by forinti on Sunday December 20, 2020 @04:10PM (#25489537)
Most 8 bit micros were designed to be just as cheap as possible.

The Beeb was a really well designed machine (both the hardware and the software). You could only expect the next step to be a great machine.

Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by mannykannot on Sunday December 20, 2020 @04:19PM (#25489619)
Even so, going from designing computers using off-the-shelf components to creating your own processor design with an innovative architecture was a bold and risky bet. Not many computer manufacturers took this route.
Re:The Acorn Archimedes and the first ARM processor by rbanffy on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:25PM (#25500380)
It mostly killed Acorn. Olivetti acquired them.