News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by jkingsbery on Sunday December 20, 2020 @10:05AM (#25486669)
I think the author has a very different definition of "fair" than what I usually think of it (free from favoritism; conforming to established rules; see https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fair).
Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by aidenn0 on Sunday December 20, 2020 @10:10AM (#25486704)
One reason why life isn't fair is that there are contradictory definitions of fair. Unfairness is a poor criticism of any system, because there isn't a completely fair system.
Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by calibas on Sunday December 20, 2020 @10:50AM (#25487044)
Which makes all this mainly about personal values and not "objective truths".
Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by aidenn0 on Sunday December 20, 2020 @01:06PM (#25488190)
That's only true if you accept moral relativism.
Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by calibas on Sunday December 20, 2020 @10:35PM (#25491908)
If morals aren't relative, which ones are correct?

To me, moral relativism means that I understand other people have different morals than mine and I have to respect that. It's not some excuse to toss morals out the window.

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by aidenn0 on Sunday December 20, 2020 @11:43PM (#25492193)
If Special Relativity and Quantum Mechanics are incompatible with respect to gravity, which one is correct?

The fact that we don't know something does not then imply that that the actual truth is subjective.

The less you know the more humble you need to be, but different views do not always justify respect. To use my previous analogy: If a random person shows up to a physicist claiming to have invented anti-gravity, then they aren't going to get much respect.

Similarly if someone claims that it's a moral positive to walk into random people's houses and murder their babies, I don't have to respect that.

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by calibas on Monday December 21, 2020 @12:57AM (#25492472)
Are we talking about moral relativism, or whether actual truth is subjective? Morals are personal/cultural values, I can't imagine equating them to "actual truth".

I'm really not following how this relates to my original comment either, I meant your idea of "fairness" depends on personal values. The fact that people have different ideas of what's fair is conclusive proof.

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by aidenn0 on Monday December 21, 2020 @01:50AM (#25492672)
> Morals are personal/cultural values

This phrase is something I completely disagree with. Morals are how one ought to behave, and how one ought to behave can intersect with cultural and personal values, but is not determined by cultural and personal values.

> I'm really not following how this relates to my original comment either, I meant your idea of "fairness" depends on personal values. The fact that people have different ideas of what's fair is conclusive proof.

I missed that subtlety , I thought you meant the general discussion of whether meritocracies are good depends on personal values. That stronger statement (that I now see you didn't make) is what I was disagreeing with.

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by calibas on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:14AM (#25495628)
>Morals are how one ought to behave, and how one ought to behave can intersect with cultural and personal values, but is not determined by cultural and personal values.

There are plenty of people who believe this, that their morals are absolute, and you can refer to the Spanish Inquisition to see exactly how "evil" that kind of thinking can get. Moral relativists are saints compared to what the Catholics have done in the name of "morality".

All religious fanatics agree that morals are absolute, they just don't agree on what those morals are.

Also, and I'm sure you'll disagree, but how you quantify and qualify "merits" is based upon personal/cultural values. If you don't realize this you'll just argue endlessly with people over whose perspective is correct, not realizing you're both just viewing things through your own biases.

To me, "good morals" are trying to understand and empathize with other people, while allowing them their own unique perspective.

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by aidenn0 on Monday December 21, 2020 @01:17PM (#25497656)
> Also, and I'm sure you'll disagree, but how you quantify and qualify "merits" is based upon personal/cultural values. If you don't realize this you'll just argue endlessly with people over whose perspective is correct, not realizing you're both just viewing things through your own biases.

Actually I completely agree with this. The fact that I have biases and you have biases will cause us to both be wrong. It doesn't mean that we are equally wrong though.

> To me, "good morals" are trying to understand and empathize with other people, while allowing them their own unique perspective.

That's a moral absolutist position.

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by calibas on Monday December 21, 2020 @02:28PM (#25498426)
>That's a moral absolutist position.

It's the exact opposite, because I acknowledged those are simply my morals, they're not some universal truth that everybody else is obliged to follow.

I'm convinced moral absolutism is dangerous and a major driving force behind fanaticism and authoritarianism.

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by aidenn0 on Monday December 21, 2020 @07:12PM (#25501376)
>> That's a moral absolutist position.

> It's the exact opposite, because I acknowledged those are simply my morals, they're not some universal truth that everybody else is obliged to follow.

> I'm convinced moral absolutism is dangerous and a major driving force behind fanaticism and authoritarianism.

So is "moral absolutism is bad" the only universal moral truth?

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by calibas on Monday December 21, 2020 @08:13PM (#25501773)
Yes, you clever person, you caught me! I'm just a hypocrite who believes moral absolutism is objectively evil, in complete opposition to what I've been saying so far!

Or maybe I believe it's dangerous because of what I've seen and experienced, but I don't believe it's objectively bad because that would be extremely silly. No, it's not bad and you're not bad, I just don't agree, I just don't see things the same way.

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by aidenn0 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:14AM (#25503803)
Perhaps we are just using different terminologies, but I don't see how something can be dangerous and yet not objectively bad.

Like "I believe it's dangerous to launch nuclear warheads at people, but it's not objectively bad and I can't say you're a bad person for doing it?"

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by calibas on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:18AM (#25507793)
>I don't see how something can be dangerous and yet not objectively bad.

Driving a car is inherently dangerous, yet I certainly wouldn't call it objectively bad. There's aspects of driving that are "good" and aspects that are "bad" but it's really a mix.

Concrete philosophical definitions of "good" and "bad" don't really apply to real life. Even the "number one" moral law, don't kill other people, quickly breaks down and society has added a very long list of conditions.

Understanding that my morals are relative doesn't mean I have no concept of "good" and "bad". It means I have my own concepts while understanding that yours may be different.

Re:Meritocracies Are Unfair – and That's the Point by aidenn0 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:12PM (#25508543)
> Understanding that my morals are relative doesn't mean I have no concept of "good" and "bad". It means I have my own concepts while understanding that yours may be different.

Similarly my belief that "good" and "bad" are absolute rather than relative doesn't mean that I think I can flawlessly categorize actions correctly, and where reasonable people disagree with me, it's a signal I should reflect on my reasons for why I differ and if I'm wrong.

I think we share a similar distaste (for lack of a better word) for anyone who thinks they are 100% right.

Unless you disagree, I think we've mined all we can from the medium of HN comments. Thanks for the discussion, I've not ever had the chance to discuss these points with someone who ascribes to any firm form of moral relativism before.