Re:Firefox to ship 'network partitioning' as a new anti-trac...
by robbywashere_ on Saturday December 19, 2020 @10:25PM
(#25483585)
Time money and resources are being spent on a protection from something that should be regulated out of existence. We are now actively innovating against these tracking technologies which we are finding adversarial to our rights to privacy. Isn’t it time we ask our governments to do something about this?
Re:Firefox to ship 'network partitioning' as a new anti-trac...
by mike_d on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:51AM
(#25484902)
Legislation is a non-starter because there was always be a little island country that will allow whatever you want to exist legally on the internet as long as it generates piles of cash.
Re:Firefox to ship 'network partitioning' as a new anti-trac...
by nitwit005 on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:48AM
(#25484895)
Computer viruses, piracy, and various forms of spam are illegal and can carry harsh sentences. We all see plenty of it.
That people occasionally get caught probably does discourage some of it, but there's obviously plenty to go around. At some point you have to accept that the law won't get rid of some of this stuff.
Re:Firefox to ship 'network partitioning' as a new anti-trac...
by shakna on Sunday December 20, 2020 @07:02AM
(#25485688)
> Computer viruses, piracy, and various forms of spam are illegal and can carry harsh sentences. We all see plenty of it.
However, you can't expect to see a virus on every single page you visit on the web, because it isn't the norm. The presence is severely reduced because it is illegal.
Re:Firefox to ship 'network partitioning' as a new anti-trac...
by nitwit005 on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:34PM
(#25489289)
People have more than one tool, because a single tool isn't the solution to every problem.
The law helps with many social problems, but it's rather frequent to hit cases where it's either outright innefective, or the cost of enforcement exceeds the cost of the problem itself.
Re:Firefox to ship 'network partitioning' as a new anti-trac...
by ec109685 on Saturday December 19, 2020 @09:48PM
(#25483402)
At some point, we will have true network partitioning, where you connect with a different IP address to every domain. With IPv6 and a cooperative ISP / OS / Browser, this would be possible today. VPNs could also work work with browser makers to implement this as a fancy kind of NAT.
Re:Firefox to ship 'network partitioning' as a new anti-trac...
by zodiakzz on Saturday December 19, 2020 @10:06PM
(#25483487)
Why can't this be fixed by fake slowing down/randomizing cache reads? Are they wasting actual bandwidth making HTTP requests for already cached content?
Re:Firefox to ship 'network partitioning' as a new anti-trac...
by noodlesUK on Sunday December 20, 2020 @01:44AM
(#25484433)
Imagine that you had a time-delayed cache lookup. If a web server sent different payloads (perhaps a time stamp) on each request, and set the cache control header to be fairly long, you could determine if something was coming out of a shared cache, or if it was fresh. Hence, we need it to be cached per site (unfortunately)
Some services get away by being small enough that persecuting them costs too much but overall, laws work.
That people occasionally get caught probably does discourage some of it, but there's obviously plenty to go around. At some point you have to accept that the law won't get rid of some of this stuff.
However, you can't expect to see a virus on every single page you visit on the web, because it isn't the norm. The presence is severely reduced because it is illegal.
Seems to me making it impossible rather than simply illegal was a much stronger driver of virus-free web browsing.
That makes absolutely no sense at all.
The law helps with many social problems, but it's rather frequent to hit cases where it's either outright innefective, or the cost of enforcement exceeds the cost of the problem itself.
That's Tor for you.
For different sites, Tor creates a different final IP/circuit.