News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Have Resigned from the Google AMP Advisory Committee by roenxi on Friday December 18, 2020 @08:11PM (#25474033)
Your incredulity isn't much of an argument. A blogger is usually some person at a keyboard, typing. A journalist is the same.

The major difference is people going in to journalism tend not to be domain experts or leaders in their field. That means bloggers can easily substitute for investigative journalism - university professors, for example, are usually better researchers than news reporters.

In fact, in this rather divided era, it is fair to question character of most journalists and ask exactly what is positive about their contribution. Good intentions do not make good outcomes, and for most things I care about the formal media is more effective at silencing real concerns than amplifying them. Bloggers sometimes get upset about issues that are important to me and tend to sustain the coverage for years. Consider https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Groklaw . No competition I'm aware of in the media circuits for that sort of work. I'll take the bloggers thanks.

Re:I Have Resigned from the Google AMP Advisory Committee by nescioquid on Friday December 18, 2020 @10:12PM (#25474640)
Amateur journalism came into my awareness through reading about Lovecraft. My impression is that people engaged in journalism for various hobby/interest groups, clubs through at least the 1920s and considered themselves amateurs in the sense of practice for the love of the activity itself. I can see a similar strand in 'zines and later web logs and blogs.

A rather older sense of "profession" (maybe concurrent with people calling themselves amateur journalists) meant any job which entailed a primary responsibility to the public, like a doctor, a lawyer, or a journalist. Unlike the other professions, one didn't need any educational credentials, bonding or special license to be a journalist.

Journalism is unique among the professions: in at least some sense of the word, if one considers oneself a journalist, one is a journalist.