Re:Justin Amash Introduces Bill to End Civil Asset Forfeitur...
by vmception on Friday December 18, 2020 @12:54PM
(#25469833)
It is paradoxical. The reality is that many constitutions around the world have aspects that contradict and can overrule other rights afforded in them, and America is no exception despite the advertisement to the contrary.
In this case because the human is not on trial, they don't get to exercise those rights.
I trust you that there probably are many court decisions that have found civil forfeiture not to be unconstitutional. But it feels like it comes down to some pedantic twisting of words which go against the spirit of the constitution.