OSI people tend to be as hostile, if not more, towards Free Software as people who write proprietary software, who simply think of it as a competitor that they rarely have to worry about (because their customers don't use it.) Open Source competes with Free Software for contributors, although it offers them nothing but the glory of helping multibillion-dollar corporations for free. At least Free Software gives you the ideological reward of contributing to the commons in an inalienable way.
I don't see how this is a true statement. Open Source is clearly a subset of Free Software. Free Software is, largely, Open Source software that also respects user freedom.
Unless you are making the claim that the "respects user freedom" part of Free Software is so huge as to make up 90% (or some other large percentage) of the importance of "Free Software"... but I don't really agree with that claim.
> since anybody can take Open Source and add whatever restrictions they want to its licensing
Well, no, not really. Copyleft licenses are free software licenses, but are also generally Open Source licenses. You can't add restrictions to copyleft licenses (in most cases). And while it's true that you can fork and add restrictions to your modifications when the original work is licensed under many of the weaker open-source licenses, that does not make the original work further encumbered. Someone can come along and take the original work, keep the license, and make modifications under that same license.
No. Open Source software also respects user freedom. OSI definition of Open Source license is pretty much compatible with FSF definition of Free Software license. Those terms are mostly interchangeable - but the whole point is that while technically they're similar, philosophically they point to completely different concepts.
> Unless you are making the claim that the "respects user freedom" part of Free Software is so huge as to make up 90% (or some other large percentage) of the importance of "Free Software"... but I don't really agree with that claim.
That's the exact claim of the article you're commenting under. And I happen to agree with that claim. User freedom is what's important, the rest are just consequences of respecting user freedom.
After all, in his initial announcement to create Gnu, he didn't say, "Of course it might turn out to perform worse, and it won't have near as many features, nor attract many other developers, or have a sane review process, or be secure... but that doesn't matter because it's all in the interest of freedom and that's the model people should follow." No, as with the OSI, he set out with some bold claims, then inspired people to help by incrementally making those claims be true.
Anyway, I fail to see how anything bad would have happened from him making this clever play. What would have been wrong with going to open source conferences, and eventually reaching a larger audience with his prescient warnings about mass surveillance, DRM, and whatnot?