Re:Ask PG: Can we have comment scores back please?
by famblycat on Friday May 13, 2011 @05:37PM
(#2546289)
>> I actually am able to digest the content from all of the comments, simply because I'm forced to devote a few moments more to them than before, rather than jumping to the "Top Votes"
I see your point. But for me, I often don't have time to digest everything. So if I'm going to only read some of the comments, I'd rather quickly find the best ones and read those.
I guess it just depends on your approach to how you consume HN comments. That's probably why this topic is so divisive.
Re:Ask PG: Can we have comment scores back please?
by alain94040 on Friday May 13, 2011 @05:39PM
(#2546295)
+1
I hate the new system. Can I be any more explicit?
EDIT: I'm at -1 now and that's ok, because I have no other way to share my approval of the parent comment. If you enjoy reading long threads of +1, keep the scores hidden.
- I actually am able to digest the content from all of the comments, simply because I'm forced to devote a few moments more to them than before, rather than jumping to the "Top Votes"
-I post less, simply because I've already seen my opinion argued in the less prominent comments. I've noticed that since comment volume is down, this must be the same for others as well. This just decreases the overall noise in the comments themselves
- There's less votebait comments now that the comment number has become downplayed. Many of the "Top Voted" comments were intentionally written to garner votes, rather than to encourage group discussion and knowledge.
I'm personally for this switch, and I'd even argue that removing post scores would be a step in the right direction as well, based on my opinion of the comment score removal.