News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by shireboy on Thursday December 17, 2020 @09:15AM (#25455714)
Anybody have tips on how to get to this level of solder-fu?
Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by tsomctl on Thursday December 17, 2020 @09:54AM (#25456079)
Flux, practice, flux, good tools, flux, good lighting, flux.

Really, learning how to braze and weld steel helped me a lot. Heat control is extremely important. Heat flows, and you learn how to position your iron to get the heat where you need it. You can also tell how hot something is by how the puddle looks.

Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by DanBC on Thursday December 17, 2020 @10:07AM (#25456179)
Basic soldering is easy to improve with practice. A couple of hours with a few hundred assorted components and some scrap PCBs will help to perfect the steps (tin the bit, hold the bit to the joint, apply the solder, pull the solder wire away, pull the bit away, inspect the joint). Things are a little bit trickier today because the alloy of the solder and the flux you use do make a difference, but lead-free solder today is very good.

Then practice with PVC insulated wire. The PVC insulation shrinks if it gets hot so this is good practice at speeding up.

I looked through the NASA document and most of it is not advance technique.

EDIT: people are saying "good tools" and I wanted to say a bit more about that. You can buy an iron for a few dollars from ebay. Don't use those. But almost any iron above that is going to be fine. I'd prefer to always be using Weller or Hako, but failing that any of the chinese no-name irons with temperature control are going to be good enough for most hobbyist projects. I love my Lindstrom and Bahco snips, but you can get good-enough cutters much cheaper. If this is something you're going to be doing all day every day you'll want to invest in the tools.

Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by function_seven on Thursday December 17, 2020 @11:58AM (#25457403)
> Basic soldering is easy to improve with practice

If you're looking for a practical way to do this, consider hand-wiring your own keyboard. I did this a couple years back, with 75 keys or so. With the diodes on each key, it was about 225 solder joints plus whatever extra to land the matrix leads on the microcontroller.

Good variety, too. Some were wire-to-wire joints, others were wire wrapped around post, and a few where through-hole joints.

If I look at the underside of that keyboard, I can tell where I started and where I finished by how clean the solder joints look :)

Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by buescher on Thursday December 17, 2020 @11:22AM (#25456977)
I wouldn't give up my Metcal for anything else I've seen, but if I were broke, I'd buy one of the Chinese Hakko clones and eventually replace the tips with Hakko tips.
Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by xxs on Thursday December 17, 2020 @11:24AM (#25456990)
T12 and flux, 37/63 solder, brass tip cleaner, flush cutter for through hole. Plus practice and more flux.
Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by mcshicks on Thursday December 17, 2020 @12:09PM (#25457524)
I found these videos from eevblog extremely helpful when I setup my home lab after working as an EE for many years but never really learning to solder.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J5Sb21qbpEQ

Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by inamberclad on Thursday December 17, 2020 @09:57AM (#25456096)
Heat control. Cleanliness. High quality tools and solder.
Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by buescher on Thursday December 17, 2020 @11:03AM (#25456772)
Temperature control is so inexpensive these days you should not bother with heat control. Unless by heat control you mean the right size tip for the job, in which case we agree.
Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by inamberclad on Friday December 18, 2020 @01:27PM (#25470213)
I meant in a more general sense, both temperature and heat flux.
Re:NASA's Through-Hole Workmanship Req (2002) by buescher on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @09:13AM (#25517795)
Not for you, but for those that might not get the point: the world of electronics assembly is really strange - it's like the whole past is present with us. It's 2021 and you can still buy a Weller soldering station with a knob for open-loop power (= heat) control for more than you'll pay for a cheapish station with closed-loop temperature control from any number of Chinese brands. (google "Hakko 936 clone"), Closed-loop temperature control is much superior to open-loop power control.