News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Elderly patients 23% more likely to die if surgery is on the surgeon’s birthday. Parent comment

Re:Elderly patients 23% more likely to die if surgery is on ... by nkurz on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:32PM (#25446336)
This is a great point to raise, but it's worth noting that it directly contradicts the GP's anecdotal observation. Had they instead found greater severity on birthdays and attempted to statistically correct for it, the two would be compatible. Instead, they looked, and found that there was no underlying difference to correct for. The question then becomes whether the GP is wrong, whether the hospital in question didn't have such a policy, or whether the measurements used in the study were insufficient to pick up the difference in severity.

I don't know which of these is true, but despite the apparent statistical significance of the finding, I wouldn't be confident assuming that the result is generally applicable. While not impossible, it strikes me as suspicious that they found no differences whatsoever in the surgeons' birthday vs non-birthday schedules. I somewhat wonder if by "no difference" they really meant "no statistically significant difference", which in this case wouldn't justify their lack of adjustment.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Elderly patients 23% more likely to die if surgery is on ... by waterhouse on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @03:48PM (#25448400)
Furthermore, note that there really is a significant "avoiding surgeries on birthdays" effect: 2064 in 980,876 operations were done on a birthday, which is 1 in 475, rather than the 1 in 365 if there were no such effect. That's a reduction of 23%, which is rather suspicious given that we're trying to explain a 23% increase in mortality rate.

So what mechanism is responsible for that reduction, and is it likely to affect surgeries differently based on how urgent and specialized (and therefore dangerous) they are? Since the authors restricted it to surgeons that have done at least one surgery on their birthday, that rules out blanket "never on birthday" policies. It seems like the only mechanism that wouldn't affect them differently is "the surgeon is already on vacation in another country and can't get here for the operation" (and they choose to take vacations on their birthday more frequently). One could probably check vacation-day records relatively easily...

[ Parent | on HN ]