Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation".
by atakan_gurkan on Friday May 13, 2011 @06:01AM
(#2544130)
Punctuation is supposed to remove ambiguities, and help you read and understand more easily. In your example
He said, "I've been outside.".
the collection of punctuation marks does very little for making the sentence more understandable, and (IMHO) looks ugly. The name "logical punctuation" is just a name for the style, do not take the word "logical" too literally.
Perhaps "compositional" would be more appropriate.
No, the second one would be written:
He said, "I've been outside."
It's implicit in the closing quotes that you've reached a pause or end of some kind.
Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation".
by zwischenzug on Friday May 13, 2011 @10:56AM
(#2544848)
Not necessarily:
He said, "I've been outside.", but I don't believe him.
I don't see a conflict there:
He said, "I've been outside", but I don't believe him.
The period within the quotes adds nothing.
Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation".
by zwischenzug on Tuesday May 17, 2011 @12:16PM
(#2556797)
It adds that that the sentence is complete.
Consider:
He said, "The world".
vs
He said, "The world.".
vs
He said, "The world [...]".
The Rise of "Logical Punctuation".
and
He said, "I've been outside".
?
To me, "logical" punctuation in the first case would be as written, and in the second case would be:
He said, "I've been outside.".
indicating that both the enclosing and enclosed sentence is complete.