News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation". by javert on Friday May 13, 2011 @05:42AM (#2544096)
I think the American style looks better in non-fixed-width fonts, because it looks much closer to the way actual handwriting should look: the comma or period underneath the quotation mark.

I suspect this is the reason people started doing it that way in the first place.

And I suspect people started doing it that way on both sides of the Atlantic. It's just that Britain ended up standardizing one way, America the other. (Possibly yet another instance of English language usage evolving more quickly in Britain than in America.)

I'd appreciate if anybody can confirm or deny this hypothesis. And I find it disappointing that the Slate article has no historical treatment of the issue.

(Honestly, both styles look weird to me in fixed-width fonts, which basically arose in tandem with the modern computer.)

Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation". by vorg on Friday May 13, 2011 @07:54AM (#2544306)
Computer fonts nowadays should be able to change ." and ". so the . is under the " and ditto ," and ", so the , is under the "
Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation". by bonzoesc on Friday May 13, 2011 @09:09AM (#2544463)
Somebody should totally engineer a font that does that; if Zapfino can have a special ligature for "Zapfino," you could certainly make ones for '".', '",', and '";'.

And yes, I just mixed punctuation styles. Period-in-quotes simply looks better.

Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation". by adrianN on Friday May 13, 2011 @10:34AM (#2544773)
I thought the font had a ligature for the string "Zapfino,". That was confusing.
Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation". by EdiX on Friday May 13, 2011 @02:30PM (#2545617)
You should be able to do it in TeX with \kern.
Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation". by Silhouette on Saturday May 14, 2011 @01:06PM (#2548054)
The technology to do this has been around for some time if you want to. However, this is the first time I recall seeing anyone advocate it for normal usage, and I have never encountered a pro-grade font that is typeset this way by default. Why would you want to remove potentially significant ordering information from punctuation, particularly when multiple punctuation marks in close proximity tend to be confusing enough already?
Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation". by billswift on Friday May 13, 2011 @11:08AM (#2544890)
Actually, fixed-width fonts arose with the typewriter, which is how these sorts of differences have had time to get established. Variable-width fonts basically didn't exist except in professionally published documents before computers and word processing.
Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation". by javert on Friday May 13, 2011 @11:51AM (#2545031)
You're right that fixed-width fonts would have arisen with the typewriter, my mistake.

Variable-width fonts basically didn't exist except in...

You're not giving enough credit to the printing press. Consider newspapers and books (even the Bible, which practically everybody read), which (I imagine) were printed with variable-width fonts for centuries, right from "the beginning" (i.e. Gutenburg).

Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation". by ghaff on Friday May 13, 2011 @12:21PM (#2545136)
Right--but newspapers and books are "professionally published documents." Latterly, there were variable-width fonts in typewriters but that was relatively late in the history of that instrument.
Re:The Rise of "Logical Punctuation". by javert on Friday May 13, 2011 @01:57PM (#2545503)
there were variable-width fonts in typewriters but that was relatively late in the history of that instrument

Interesting, I did not know that.