Bro, I'm answering your question as to why cows cause a global warming crisis and bison did not.
You're intentionally being obtuse on that point though, right? Like yeah, cows may be just like bison in a very very narrow frame of reference, but bison did not get their food trucked to them & they did not cut down trees to graze (both of which are things cows require now).
That's why. Period.
EDIT: If you want to narrow your frame of reference even further & just talk about methane, then 1) It's not the main culprit so I guess we agree there. But again, Global Warming is a cumulative thing, so they fact that they product that methane AND require carbon emissions to exist is pretty bad. 2) Yeah, it's a crude estimate, that's why I almost doubled it to give you the benefit of the doubt.
I'm addressing the specific, and oft-repeated, claim that cow farts as such somehow magically put more carbon in the air than there was before.
Now, there may be other issues associated with cattle raising, but that is not, and has never been, my point.
Since you apparently do not dispute my main point, I think we're finished here.
P.S. After reading your reference on the pre-European number of bison more carefully, your claim of 30 million is not supported at all by the author. The previous estimates given in the paper range all over the place, up to 1 billion (!). The author is careful to point out that all of those numbers are more or less junk, and the only conclusion the author actually makes is that there were "likely" "tens of millions" of bison.
That does not match your claim of a hard 30 million.
And btw, what's your endgame here? Climate Change denialism? I hope not, b/c that's a real bummer.
Just as I said.
I'm not sure why that counts as "moving goalposts".
And my "endgame" here is to not doom billions of people in the Third World to starvation because modern agricultural methods offend the sensibilities of privileged white people living in an affluent society.
That's not answering my question.
Any atom of carbon emitted by a cow was almost certainly removed from the atmosphere by a plant quite recently, yes?
So how is that not a carbon-neutral cycle?
We're talking about the specific claim that cow digestion, in and of itself, leads to increased carbon levels in the atmosphere. Clearly it does not, and cannot.
Talking about the rain forest is shifting the goalposts.
Note that North America has more forest land than it did a hundred years ago, largely because modern mechanized agriculture has dramatically increased the crop yield per acre, leading to marginal agricultural land being returned to forest cover.
The "slash-and-burn" agricultural methods that destroy the rain forest are largely a feature of the "low tech" "traditional" "organic" farming techniques that are beloved by environmentalists.