Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants
by didibus on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @04:04PM
(#25435235)
> I want smaller companies, which don't abuse data, which don't sacrifice security for 'hypergrowth', who are able to moderate their content and comply with laws rather than ignore them, and so on
Why would smaller companies be better positioned for those things?
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants
by Barrin92 on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @04:46PM
(#25435634)
because a larger number of smaller companies increases competition, meaning users can realistically leave, making firms accountable to their community (ask yourself why discourse on HN or a mastodon instance is more civil than on Facebook, for example). More human-scale size enables human content moderation.
any given smaller company is non-essential, meaning it cannot challenge lawmakers on the grounds of being essential, or bully lawmakers into submission.
Smallness also incentivises business models that aren't data-analytics driven because small companies simply lack huge pools of user-data, hopefully diminishing the toxic surveillance-capital model of predominantly large firms.
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants
by cmarschner on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @05:59PM
(#25436512)
This doesn’t work when there are network effects. We had enough smaller social networks in Europe but they were all eventually subsumed by a US companies like fb, Twitter ir LinkedIn.
Also, the US has 50% of the worldwide online advertisement market in a single cultural region.
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants
by cabalamat on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @03:49PM
(#25435066)
> I don't even want to compete with Facebook just to have European Facebook, it'd suck just as much.
I want smaller companies, which don't abuse data, which don't sacrifice security for 'hypergrowth'
The EU needs to create rules to reward small companies and to curb large ones.
There's two things the EU could do here: force big companies to split up (so they can't favour their own services) and require social networks to be interoperable (using ActivityPub or similar).
the issue is even deeper. You can't compete without recreating the same issues that those giants already have in the US or China. I don't even want to compete with Facebook just to have European Facebook, it'd suck just as much.
I want smaller companies, which don't abuse data, which don't sacrifice security for 'hypergrowth', who are able to moderate their content and comply with laws rather than ignore them, and so on. Companies like this will never compete with American or Chinese giants in a 'free market'. It's like having a green energy company compete with companies that can legally pour their waste into the river.
The EU needs to create rules to reward small companies and to curb large ones. Don't copy "maximal consumer welfare" doctrines or prioritise convenience, promote decentralisation. It looks like there's some good stuff in these new laws, but they don't go far enough yet.