Frankly some of my best comments have been downvoted. If there's nothing obviously deficient and no one offers a correction, I consider it possible that it was because it threatened someone's worldview. People will go to great lengths to protect their worldview, downvoting is nothing on that scale.
I really wish downvoting was replaced with a flagging feature. The official guidelines are pretty easy to follow and fairly effective in labelling the sorts of comments that take the conversation backwards. If someone is arguing in bad faith, they're likely in contravention of one of the guidelines, in which case moderation is a more appropriate tool for the problem.
> The official guidelines are pretty easy to follow and fairly effective in labelling the sorts of comments that take the conversation backwards.
I think there are marginal cases for every rule.
Perhaps, but I think having the >500 karma rule for flagging would ensure users understand the gravity of their actions, somewhat. I find up-votes on comments to be rare, and down-votes to be a couple of orders of magnitude rarer. Part of that will be transitive of the rarity of the down-vote privilege, but I think those people having been subjected to fairly received down-votes makes them use the power with a little more discretion once they've earned it.
> I think there are marginal cases for every rule.
Don't disagree with this, but the HN interface is a blunt tool. I'm of the persuasion that a flagging privilege would likely have a positive impact vs a down-voting privilege, but it's hard to know without an experiment, and also hard to measure. The system as it is, is 'good enough', and most members are conservative regarding the interface, so there's hardly a motivation to try.
I'm more interested in furthering 'the discourse' than reclaiming silly karma points. It's just nice to know where people think I'm wrong, and beings able to discuss why that might be.