I still don't understand why??? I can understand if users want a shop they can trust, which Apple could deliver with their iTunes shop. But how would it hurt users if there were also other shops? The paranoid ones simply would not use those other shops.
I'm guessing you don't use a Mac, or keep close with Mac users. The attitude is entirely one-sided: it's all about quality, period. Many Mac users eschew Firefox for Safari, because the one is so much better-made, even if it doesn't let you use StumbleUpon and whatnot. Word 2008 is attacked by Mac users for feeling too much like Windows. Even the App Store is being attacked right now for being too LOW-standards.
Apple's idea is this: if your idea is too poor to be displayed on their store, you should design for something that isn't working with Apple software. That's not a disadvantage. It's a mindset that ensures top-notch design, time and time again. It's why most people will pick up an Apple product and assume that it works well. It's because Apple controls everything, and because that's a good thing.
Also, I thought Apple promised to let basically every application into the store?
Without that, it would be mad to develop for the iPhone. It would be a huge gamble, spending maybe 5 digit sums or more only to hear that you did not live up to Apple's standards and can throw your application into the garbage bin.
Maybe there is another reason: maybe sales of mobile applications are a huge market, and Apple simply doesn't want to share.
"Facebook desperately wants to find a way to help application developers make money beyond advertising, and the iPhone App Store has shown that people are willing to pay for quality applications."
Praise be to the iPhone AppStore! No one had thought of charging for applications before. Who knew that people would pay for software?