We live in a legal regime where it's not even permissible to take sunken treasure that's near countries, even after centuries at sea. But somehow land stolen from indigenous people and Black people more recently is somehow unrecoverable? We need to at least write down in our laws the rationale for this.
More immediately pertinent: why were these thefts substantially different from those the Supreme Court ruled against in Oklahoma?
If we're not willing to at least do that much, yeah we should just give it back. The alternative is choosing lawlessness, which is not something we are bound to do.
We don't have to worry about converting to dollars because we can just return title to the land itself. The Supreme Court did the same this year in Oklahoma, so it wouldn't even be unprecedented.
https://www.reuters.com/article/usa-court-oklahoma/us-suprem...
Do we repay them as well? And how many trillions (since that’s there value of such land now, with or without interest)