News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Timnit Gebru: Google and big tech are 'institutionally ra... by rvz on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:25PM (#25424804)
At this point in their view, Everything is 'institutionally racist'™

Being a victim is now cool again I suppose. The new 'blames the government for everything' rhetoric is now applied to tech companies.

Re:Timnit Gebru: Google and big tech are 'institutionally ra... by leoh on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:36PM (#25424917)
Roman, remember by your strength to rule

Earth’s peoples—for your arts are to be these:

To pacify, to impose the rule of law,

To spare the conquered, battle down the proud.

(VI.1151–1154) [Virgil's Aeneid]

---

We need more compassion in this world, not less; especially for the defeated. For Gebru, even for those at Google that have, in my view, erred; to do otherwise is to drown ourselves in misery; to race one another towards the bottom; to view the world merely as zero sum.

Re:Timnit Gebru: Google and big tech are 'institutionally ra... by epistasis on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:38PM (#25424937)
I would characterize it slightly differently, rather than everything "being" institutionally racist, it's more like racism creeps into all of our institutions. Instead of thinking of racism as a yes/no binary with intention, I think it's more useful to think of it as something like "fairness." Can an institution have an intention of being more or less fair? Maybe, but it doesn't really matter. We usually want our institutions to treat everyone fairly, and when they fail to act fairly, it's sometimes because a person wanted them to be unfair, but more commonly just because of systemic effects that randomly combine into unfairness.

So it is with racism in our society and institutions. It starts with housing and education. Housing is still as racially segregated as it was in the 1970s, and that leads to massive differences in average opportunities. Which leads to familial wealth gaps, and which leads to further disparity, because families that can't help a member that has a broken car, for example, can set back a person early in their career when they get fired because of it. Which leads to further snowballing of opportunity and financial pain. It's like starting the game of Monopoly when a bunch of the players have had dozens of turns of head start. Even if the game is "fair" in that there are no explicit barriers to buying and selling a property or paying rent when landing on somebody else's, it's unfair because the staring financial position was quite different.

So this can't all fall on tech companies, of course, but as major pillars of modern society, they bear some responsibility of fixing the problems that persist.

Re:Timnit Gebru: Google and big tech are 'institutionally ra... by HexagonalKitten on Monday December 14, 2020 @07:22PM (#25425343)
American racism, in housing for example, didn't creep in. It came in a bang with slavery and has been going away, in fits and starts ever since.

How do you get from there to:

> racism creeps into all of our institutions. Instead of thinking of racism as a yes/no binary with intention, I think it's more useful to think of it as something like "fairness."

All? I think you should consider "I'm not racist, there are much better reasons to hate people." Even if you find unfairness somewhere, and even if it's intentional, how do you know a priori that it's because of skin color?

> It's like starting the game of Monopoly when a bunch of the players have had dozens of turns of head start.

Right. American Descendants of Slavery (ADoS) really have a shitty position. Worse off from the start and sometimes still facing the racism.

> So this can't all fall on tech companies, of course, but as major pillars of modern society, they bear some responsibility of fixing the problems that persist.

If it's our society's responsibility to fight slavery, have you hunted a pimp? Or do you expect your tax dollars to fund the police who do such things? I expect Google to not try to make things worse, but I'm fine if all the good they do comes from taxes.

Re:Timnit Gebru: Google and big tech are 'institutionally ra... by nowledge on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:33PM (#25424880)
what victims are cool? history is filled with aggressors we idolize, i don't know a victim. asking honestly.
Re:Timnit Gebru: Google and big tech are 'institutionally ra... by pas on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:45PM (#25425017)
Wasn't Jesus a victim?
Re:Timnit Gebru: Google and big tech are 'institutionally ra... by threatofrain on Monday December 14, 2020 @07:09PM (#25425225)
More importantly, Jesus is considered by many to be the son of God, as well as God himself. Otherwise Jesus would just be a victim.
Re:Timnit Gebru: Google and big tech are 'institutionally ra... by corty on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:06PM (#25425748)
It is a reinterpretation of victimhood to be noble and glorious to appeal to the masses, who are or see themselves as predominantly victims.
Re:Timnit Gebru: Google and big tech are 'institutionally ra... by loopz on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:54PM (#25426115)
Jesus only said to love one another, have compassion, care for even thieves and hookers, meet people as they are not how you want them to be.