Re:Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
by AnimalMuppet on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:08PM
(#25424642)
I think I know, too, and I differ from you.
I think the post people are asking about got downvoted because you are saying thinks like "Discomfitingly, 'the world' or 'society' is really just an idea in an individual's mind - these are just ideas that don't exist independently of individuals." And you're just stating it like it's true, with no justification.
More, you're saying "Discomfitingly", like this "truth" is obviously true but we don't want to hear it because we don't like it. If nothing else, that violates the site guideline of the principle of charity. But I think it's deeper than that. I suspect that you maybe actually think that - that you're actually, obviously right, and anyone who disagrees with you is deliberately blind. That kind of attitude draws downvotes any time it escapes into your words.
In particular, the parent post to this one. I'm surprised that it isn't downvoted. In fact, I did downvote it, purely for the "you're a bunch of whining crybabies with your heads in the sand because you downvoted me" that runs all through it.
And:
> Worst to me, is that HN facilitates teeny, tiny acts of violence against me.
If you think downvotes (or being rate limited) are violence, you need to separate your identity from your words.
I think the post people are asking about got downvoted because you are saying thinks like "Discomfitingly, 'the world' or 'society' is really just an idea in an individual's mind - these are just ideas that don't exist independently of individuals." And you're just stating it like it's true, with no justification.
More, you're saying "Discomfitingly", like this "truth" is obviously true but we don't want to hear it because we don't like it. If nothing else, that violates the site guideline of the principle of charity. But I think it's deeper than that. I suspect that you maybe actually think that - that you're actually, obviously right, and anyone who disagrees with you is deliberately blind. That kind of attitude draws downvotes any time it escapes into your words.
In particular, the parent post to this one. I'm surprised that it isn't downvoted. In fact, I did downvote it, purely for the "you're a bunch of whining crybabies with your heads in the sand because you downvoted me" that runs all through it.
And:
> Worst to me, is that HN facilitates teeny, tiny acts of violence against me.
If you think downvotes (or being rate limited) are violence, you need to separate your identity from your words.