News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software Needs Philosophers (2006) by contingencies on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:43PM (#25424372)
To make the same points but get less of a harsh response, maybe try improving your comments by talking in the third person. In short, don't take things personally.
Re:Software Needs Philosophers (2006) by feralimal on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:54PM (#25424484)
Why? I am a person, and I am making my personal observations.

I am happy to hear other perspectives, wisdom, understanding.

I'm not that interested in people not engaging with the ideas presented, as the form is difficult.

This is sort of my point - that individuals shouldn't write themselves out of the picture.

Re:Software Needs Philosophers (2006) by contingencies on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:58PM (#25424538)
I agree in principle. Unfortunately, the audience's brain does not work with logic, it works with emotion.
Re:Software Needs Philosophers (2006) by feralimal on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @03:50AM (#25428342)
Yes. Everyone is so used to being manipulated, and, it seems, without the ability to work things personally, according to their principles. (Do people even know what principles are? Is it whatever is expedient or are there lines that cannot be crossed?)

They actually prefer sugar-coated bullshit to honest responses. They do not use logic, it is all emotional responding. Their ears or eyes cannot take honesty, and they actually feel psychologically assaulted by honestly stated propositions.

For myself, I intentionally don't play that game. I don't seek to manipulate or sell ideas to others. I want people to engage with the ideas or not. And I'm fine either way. But I get slammed in this thread and others, not because I may be wrong (and I may be) but just because they don't like the simple, unadorned, probably true, message.

If this is where we are at on hackernews, in a thread about philosophy, it speaks volumes about how much trouble we are in as a group, and how we will not be getting out of it anytime soon. The only solution they see is to close down voices like mine.

Re:Software Needs Philosophers (2006) by contingencies on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @07:02AM (#25429480)
Amen brother. Try voicing a balanced perspective on China some time...
Re:Software Needs Philosophers (2006) by feralimal on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @08:43AM (#25430189)
Cheers. I'd be interested to hear what experiences you have had. Feel free to point me to a thread, or conversation...
Re:Software Needs Philosophers (2006) by contingencies on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @11:19PM (#25439008)
Have you met my friend Eliza?