News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software Needs Philosophers (2006) by AnimalMuppet on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:33PM (#25420372)
> That's just logistics - it comes after your philosophical understanding of the item. We don't have to monitor things that aren't bad. We monitor nuclear proliferation because we've already made a philosophical judgement on it. It came first.

That's true, I suppose, but unskilled laborers routinely achieve the level of philosophical sophistication required to make that judgment. It doesn't help your argument about the primacy of philosophy if it means the kind of "philosophy" achieved by the man in the street.

> We don't have climate policy because people stand to lose money, just like we have software engineers that refuse to take pay cuts to work on actual helpful technology instead of adtech.

That's true, but we also don't have a society that will pay more for actual helpful technology than it will for adtech. Why blame the software engineers for not making themselves martyrs? Why not blame the CEOs for not making themselves martyrs? Why not blame the people for wanting the wrong things?

Re:Software Needs Philosophers (2006) by ntsplnkv2 on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:32PM (#25421231)
I'm not sure what exclusivity has to do with primacy.

In any case that is an easy example. But what about the example of the use of the atomic bombs in Hiroshima? That is much more debatable and isn't as clear cut - so we need more advanced discussions to make a better decision in that case.

> That's true, but we also don't have a society that will pay more for actual helpful technology than it will for adtech. Why blame the software engineers for not making themselves martyrs? Why not blame the CEOs for not making themselves martyrs? Why not blame the people for wanting the wrong things?

I'm not arguing that software engineers should be martyrs. I'm arguing that software engineers bear culpability as much as anyone else, and to suggest that they are more necessary than philosophy as incorrect.

You touch an important problem. We could have a discussion about the ethics - who is responsible, who is not. What do you know - philosophy.