It’s not a question of whether it’s priced in, it’s about giving everyone the same starting line.
This was a really thoughtless comment in my opinion
My hunch is that the risk factor this introduces is at least an order of magnitude less significant than other risk factors, like having an appropriate go to market strategy or proper customer base research.
> If you can identify an overlooked segment of founders, you can invest in that group and get industry beating returns.
I described a way that might be false. I did not make any moral claim, and certainly don't think that "actual sexism should take place during funding."
Please be more thoughtful yourself.
If sexism towards female founders in the intended market is a major risk factor (I don’t believe it can be considered major, which is up for debate), then it’s a VCs opportunity to cut through to the core of what makes the _business_ and its _products_ viable... not simply to pass because the market won’t like a female founder as much as a male founder.
But then that’s what a VC should be doing anyway. So founder gender and any perception of market bias towards that should become an increasingly insignificant factor in the funding process.
Not that I disagree with your argument, but pointing out it is on different grounds than what it was posted in response to.
But as others became aware of the advantage, the overlooked group of people would find themselves more sought after. And that would drive up their wages and increase their opportunities.
The wage gap is mostly a motherhood gap. For those women who choose to become mothers, suddenly there are more important things in life than the company's priorities. They start falling behind women who didn't have children, and men who carry less of the work of the household. This is surprisingly not common knowledge by now even though it's well supported by data and well discussed by feminists, including Hillary Clinton. Speaking about populations in general and not individuals - women with children on average earn less because work isn't the highest priority in their lives. I think they're the smart ones.
The other major component of the wage gap is that women on average aren't as well represented in higher paying fields like STEM fields, or work that's physically dangerous and undesirable - but pays well. With that latter segment of jobs, again one could argue women are being smarter about it. This is true even in the most enlightened countries like the Scandinavian countries - in fact it's more true there. I think the only way to address that is to get it into the heads of young girls who're still in school that those STEM jobs can be women's jobs. How to accomplish that is still a mystery.
You say the remaining gap is a 'motherhood' gap. Someone else thinks its chauvinism. And someone else thinks it's feminist propaganda. And another thinks it's a Masonic scheme. It doesn't matter! The market will correct for whatever injustice might actually exist. But only if the law permits the market to enact a price for bigotry.
Other times, no, because it would mean that group is just as good as me, and I can’t have that.
As Friedman points out, the market punishes the bigot when the market is permitted to do so. Only the government can prevent the bigoted businessman from paying the price for his bigotry.
The underlying problem with letting the market handle things, as far as I can tell, is that the activists can't claim credit for punishment administered by the market.
Women, in recent history, have always gotten the short-end of the stick. It has taken a long time for the biases in academia to be addressed at all, and even now we aren't quite there yet. Here are a few examples from history,
Lise Meitner was the second woman in the world to gain a doctorate in physics. When she started, women weren't allowed to go to college, one of humanity's greatest minds spent her youth as a teacher. It was the only career available to her. When she tried to start doing research, she was refused,
> The only difficulty was that Hahn told me in the course of our conversation that he had been given a place in the institute directed by Emil Fischer, and that Emil Fischer did not allow any women students into his lectures or into his institute. So Hahn had to ask Fischer whether he would agree to our starting work together. And after Hahn had spoken to Fischer, I went to him to hear his decision and he told me his reluctance to accept women students stemmed from an unfortunate experience he had had with a Russian student because he had always been worried lest her rather exotic hairstyle result in her hair catching alight on the Bunsen burner.
- https://www.iaea.org/sites/default/files/publications/magazi...
Fischer relented with pressure from Hahn, but in some cases, it took nearly half a decade for people to allow her to work with them. She lost years banging her head against the wall. What else could she have discovered had she gotten the right resources from the start?
She prevailed against these barriers, but she was never recognized as an equal. Recognition eluded her. Lise and Otto discovered fission together, Hahn got the Nobel, she didn't.
Decades afterwards, the first Pulsar was detected by Jocelyn Bell Burnell. She helped build the array that made the discovery. She spent her nights looking at the data. She noticed the anomaly. She championed it when her supervisor dismissed it as a glitch. Her persistence paid off, and her supervisor got the Nobel.
Women have never been accepted as equal. Even in bastions of "non-conformist" thought such as universities. After all, how radical and non-conformist could these systems be if they repeated the same mistakes as the societies around them? They excluded people for being Jewish, for being born with the wrong sex organs, for having the wrong skin color, for being the wrong person. They were radical along some axes, but conformist along others.
VC/PE is much the same. The industry is radical along some axes but extremely conformist along others. And it's not an easy thing to "correct". Banging against this wall will crack your skull far before it shows even the slightest crack.
I don't know the answer here. Except that it wouldn't be the right stuff to give up.
Not fully utilizing a segment of the population due to discrimination is an inefficiency, and the free market will apply pressure to correct that. I don't think that's enough by itself, but it's nice to know we're rowing downstream.
In any case, she was given the highest possible honor by having an element named after herself, Meitnerium. It's absurd that she keeps appearing on those lists of allegedly overlooked female scientists.
Sure, she may have had to fight for recognition, but that is not unique to female scientists. Einstein had to work in a patent office, for example.
Similar with the story of Bell - not sure what exactly happened, but in any case she is not the only scientists who didn't get credit for her work. It happens to men on a regular basis, too. The assumption that it happened because of her gender may simply be wrong. (Edit: in the meantime she received 2.3M GBP via the "Special Breakthrough Price in Physics" https://www.cam.ac.uk/stories/journeysofdiscovery-pulsars - as for the Nobel, they are a private organization, and it may be difficult to judge for outsiders what is the elementary work in a discovery. Maybe the people who designed the telescope are more deserving than the person who manned it, or whatever).
Sadly, there are few sources discussing why women were excluded from academia in former times. I suspect part of it was the church, another economic reasons as women had a high risk of dying from childbirth, making their education a risky investment. Even today, women work less on average over their lifetime compared to men, so investing in their education has lower returns.
If you can identify an overlooked segment of founders, you can invest in that group and get industry beating returns.
I don't know the name of the VC company but I remember reading about one that only invests in female founders and not out of any charity, they correctly realized of their peers are overlooking female founders then they'll be a comparative bargain to invest in.
Research like this is great to shine a light on it and get VCs to take notice. Their money will quickly follow - that's my prediction anyway.