Re:Lenovo seeks to render Nokia's H.264 patents unenforceable
by nullc on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:19PM
(#25403748)
Building a valuable bridge that people voluntarily pay you to use is an investment.
Planting a flag next to General Dynamics driveway so that you can collect a percentage off every aircraft that goes buy is rent seeking.
If patent holders were required to specifically identify and price the technology they encumber standards with such that the standards setters can pick and choose which were worth it-- that would be a different matter, but it isn't how it works. Note that I pointed out that the specific patented technologies often have negligible or even negative benefits.
Developing the technology that has become the standard takes a lot of resources; you have spent them.
Standard bodies usually compare several technologies and pick one; you have risked that your development effort would not make it into the standard, and would be a dead end.
It looks a bit like bidding for a military contract. Did General Dynamics receive unearned windfall when USAF accepted their bid for a fighter jet, and kept paying for each F-16 they ordered? Surely the price of each included a part of the R&D costs.