Re:The YouTube ban is un-American, wrong, and will backfire
by gnusty_gnurc on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:14PM
(#25399742)
Freedoms enumerated in the bill of rights were chosen as a reflection of morality. You’re arguing utilitarianism about what’s a moral issue of the inherent right of people to express themselves.
Re:The YouTube ban is un-American, wrong, and will backfire
by UncleMeat on Saturday December 12, 2020 @12:36PM
(#25399944)
Yet you oppose certain kinds of speech outright by virtue of the fact that the population has decided via democratic legislation that they should be crimes, presumably because of the harm that they cause.
I don't believe that the intention of the framers was that free speech was a good in-and-of itself but that making it difficult (but not impossible) to restrict speech has positive outcomes. At the very least, that is my read of things.
Re:The YouTube ban is un-American, wrong, and will backfire
by gnusty_gnurc on Saturday December 12, 2020 @01:22PM
(#25400270)
The whole “unalienable rights” of individuals suggests that this isn’t a democratic notion, it’s a moral philosophy and conviction.
General restrictions on state power don't work. Capitalism crushes people. When that state power turns on the majority, the majority complains that their voices are silenced and then they go right back to ignoring the continued problems of the minority.
Perhaps the solution is to approach each situation on a case by case process. Protest and agitate when the state harms people and celebrate when the state protects people. Make harm reduction the goal.
In software people often point to how focusing on metrics can make you fail to achieve your true goal. Similarly, we should focus on the thing that free speech is intending to achieve rather than free speech itself.