News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chromebook by scott_s on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:04PM (#2537883)
Most people don't create. You must be depressed by the wasted potential, because we're going from a world where most people don't create to a world where most people don't create.
Re:Chromebook by dkarl on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:42PM (#2538057)
I don't think you ever saw ordinary people let loose with the power of "Print Shop" in the 1980s or Microsoft Word in the 1990s. People made greeting cards, family newsletters, notices, party decorations....

In the visual arts, a lot of the people who do amusing Photoshop work are not professionals. Also consider MySpace in the 2000s. You might argue that MySpace isn't a good illustration of the value of giving people creative freedom, but you can't deny that a lot of people were eager to take advantage of it.

Then there are the people who get into sound editing or musical arrangement. These days a kid might start with making a ringtone and then escalate. Personally, I'm the least "creative" and least musical person you'll ever meet, but even I spent a whole day trying to arrange a decent-sounding version of "Walk Like an Egyptian" using a digital music program on my Apple IIgs. Why "Walk Like an Egyptian?" I have no idea. When I was thirteen I recorded myself belching, reversed it, dropped the tone an octave or two, added an echo and made it the shutdown sound for Windows 3.1. I told my parents it was the sound of a WWII submarine preparing to submerge. (Eventually, I figured out that code was my preferred way of expressing myself. I had fun writing computer programs that made pretty mathematical patterns on the screen, among other things.)

Putting content creation tools in the hands of everyone is key because you never know who's going to use them. Some kid decides to make something cute or awesome or badass or smartass and the next thing you know s/he's hooked on sound editing or what-not. Unfortunately, the model of commercial software development is to give someone a free taste, then frustrate them with limitations, and then take their credit card and charge them for the pro version. Kids are easily frustrated, may not have access to a credit card, and even if they have a card, may not be able to spend $100 or more for professional-quality software.

However, I think the answer to that concern is that non-professional content creation needs will be served by free web apps.

Re:Chromebook by svjunkie on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @06:20PM (#2538648)
Non-professional content creation apps are already available in the Chrome web store. Aviary has a suite of audio-visual tools it offers, including vector image editing (I don't work for them or anything).
Re:Chromebook by ugh on Thursday May 12, 2011 @08:56AM (#2540394)
I do not understand this worry or whatever it is at all. I’m always completely baffled when someone brings it up.

Content creation has never been as cheap as today. To suggest that tablets or netbooks will somehow limit that ability seems crazy to me. Just because the software isn’t yet written? Because that’s what’s happening, the software is written and perfected (Have you seen GarageBand? Google Docs? The list goes on.) and meanwhile we are all in transition anyway. All those PCs won’t disappear overnight.

This is one of those crazy way-too-premature worries.

Re:Chromebook by eftpotrm on Thursday May 12, 2011 @01:08PM (#2541346)
Would you like to try creating extensive content on a touchscreen?

I love my netbook, it goes almost everywhere with me. I can touch type on it fast enough to take notes in meetings or from church sermons, I can write music on it, I can even run Visual Studio 2010 and SQL Server 2008 well enough to be productive with them.

I can't for one minute imagine how I'd be able to do anything like that without a hardware keyboard and I'm yet to see the add-on keyboard that's as stable for typing on my knees, in the back of a car, held in one hand while standing (or whatever) as any netbook. I've got no problem with tablets as devices but they still seem to be firmly consumption devices to me.

Re:Chromebook by ugh on Thursday May 12, 2011 @01:24PM (#2541412)
You mistakenly seem to have equated typing with creating.

Typing is a subset of creating. Tablets are not so great for typing, sure, but PCs and tablets are both cheap. There is no reason to believe that they won't co-exist, both making it easier for everyone to create.

Re:Chromebook by eftpotrm on Thursday May 12, 2011 @02:20PM (#2541690)
No, but a better input device than a touchscreen can certainly make creating easier.

When I'm creating text content, a keyboard is a fast and efficient means of data entry.

When I'm creating images or doing graphic design work, I want precision of control. A touchscreen isn't fine enough.

When I'm creating music, there are a range of input options but I'd still take some persuading that a touchscreen is quite there.

Re:Chromebook by ugh on Thursday May 12, 2011 @02:28PM (#2541740)
Your opinion. There are quite a few artists who would disagree with you about the images part.

But it still doesn’t matter. Looking at the whole picture, tablets make creating easier. That’s it. To suggest otherwise seems crazy to me.

Re:Chromebook by lachenmayer on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @06:32PM (#2538678)
However, for most kids in that category, piracy is a very viable alternative. And such access to tools which would otherwise cost hundreds of dollars can, and does, foster huge amounts of creativity in kids.
Re:Chromebook by arihant on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:18PM (#2537957)
"Most people don't create"

...and ChromeOS would change that? Availability of tools is not something that needs to immediately follow daily use.

Not all my family cooks. We still have a kitchen.

Re:Chromebook by scott_s on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:31PM (#2538008)
I'm confused by what your point is because I'm not sure if you understand mine. My point was that most people don't use their existing computers for creative purposes, so introducing a computer with limited creative potential won't change much.
Re:Chromebook by arihant on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:43PM (#2538062)
It will. Just because most people don't cook, we start selling houses without kitchen, don't you think its a slippery and wrong slope?

Look at ipad running GarageBand, thats the stuff we want. People don't create only when when creating stuff sucks. Just like I only cook when all I have to do is "add hot water".

There is a quote that comes to mind: "Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein.

Re:Chromebook by true_religion on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @06:51PM (#2538729)
Your analogy is a bit off there. You're comparing no kitchen (in a world where most people don't cooking) to limited creative avenues (in a world where most people don't create).

A limitation is not the same thing as a complete absence of potential.

After correcting your analogy, I can think of situations where landlords do not provide full kitchens---for example apartments, or temporary vacation condos or business suites.

You can technically cook, but you can't cook very much.

Re:Chromebook by scott_s on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:49PM (#2538103)
You're assuming that this new Chrome netbook-laptop-thingy will replace the typical desktop computer. I don't think it will. My parents love their iPads (yes, iPads, plural, they each have one because being retired means you no longer have to share) yet still bought a new desktop when their old one died.
Re:Chromebook by arihant on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @04:10PM (#2538201)
You're right. I was a little presumptuous there. My mind is corrupted by all the post-pc speculation going on. :)

I do think that these devices are more of an internet window. At the same time, they are in standard PC form factor. I feel chromeOS chose a bad form factor. Think about it, you are happy carrying your laptop or having a desktop with your current internet window (iPads), but imagine carrying and having chromebook with a macbook. That doesn't look like a solution, thats an ugly desk. Point being - I won't be the only one who will every now and then, mistakenly or otherwise, compare chrombooks to the PCs. If they look like one, they might as well bang like one.

Re:Chromebook by maxwell on Thursday May 12, 2011 @08:56AM (#2540393)
Browsers are winning as runtime environments, and thry include offline, local apps. The difference between Chromebooks and other devices is that apps written for the former should work on the latter. The issue isn't Chrome OS (or, say, Safari OS or Firefox OS or IEOS); what runs on my Cr-48 runs on every other device too, while apps on the iPhone in my hands and the Ubuntu desktop at my house and Windows desktop at my office all contain apps that can't run on my Cr-48.

HTML, CSS, and JS already won, in the sense that English had "won" a hundred years ago. What I'm waiting for browser performance and developers (myself included) to write apps that "bang", not webbooks that run legacy software.

Re:Chromebook by PetrolMan on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:26PM (#2537987)
Basic creation tools will still be there (Google Docs) and more tools are becoming available online to replace traditional desktop tools. I was actually just taking a good look at online IDEs...
Re:Chromebook by swah on Sunday May 15, 2011 @10:06AM (#2549958)
Some of us will only move when Chromebooks are being used to develop the software that powers a Chromebook, otherwise we'll disregard them as toys.
Re:Chromebook by kiba on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:07PM (#2537901)
People created too much stuff for us to enjoy anyway. All the books in the world on average probably got read several times, but all human beings never hope to read all the books.
Re:Chromebook by bad_user on Thursday May 12, 2011 @03:45AM (#2539750)
I can't imagine the pain you must feel with so many books around, it must be excruciating.

Certainly you haven't lived if you haven't read them all, and even if you manage that, some college punk might release yet another novel just as you find yourself in the final moments of your stressful life; Jeez, the horror.

Re:Chromebook by ippisl on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:50PM (#2538109)
I sure like the huge variety that blogs offer, don't you ?
Re:Chromebook by kiba on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @04:25PM (#2538271)
Which is why we don't need to keep encouraging people to create content. Rather, we need better way to find great content to enjoy.
Re:Chromebook by cheez on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @06:52PM (#2538731)
That doesn't sound very different.
Re:Chromebook by siglesias on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:06PM (#2537898)
Is that a cause or an effect?
Re:Chromebook by scott_s on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @03:09PM (#2537914)
I think it's probably an independent variable. Most people work, and would have to create in their free time - but that takes sincere effort during a period most people want to unwind.