News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by hpoe on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:06PM (#25375772)
I'll just throw out that I think CS degrees are a terrible idea, because the fact of the matter is there are virtually no actual CS jobs out there. I got my degree in Software Engineering instead, and I find myself far more prepared than many CS colleagues. In my degree we had classes on project management, requirements gathering, structuring and managing databases, heck one class was just about getting your A+ so you could know how to diagnose and repair misbehaving machines and understand things a little bit more holistically.

If you want to be an aeronautics engineer, or a civil engineer we don't require you to go get a degree in physics, sure you'll have a lot of classes that deal with physics and you're expected to be familiar with the basics, but you aren't going to have physics as your major. So why the heck do we keep pushing people to CS when their going into Software Engineering?

If you think as CS education is still necessary and valuable in your work as an SWE please tell me why, I am curious to understand why if people feel it was useful I want to know why.

EDIT: I appreciate the answers I've gotten, as clarification I have noticed several people cite how their degree helped them get a job, or move positions, and I agree that it does that; however I feel a degree in Software Engineering would be just as valid, in these situations. My question is more about is a does a CS degree or an SE degree help make one a better engineer?

Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by zeku on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:37PM (#25376164)
I think my degree is fantastically useful, and I'm relatively young.

There is just no way I would have ever learned the things I learned in my CS degree on my own. My degree reshaped my brain. It forced me to be good at math. It forced me to think like a programmer.

I failed my first 3 CS classes, but I kept going and ended up graduating top 5% in my CS graduating class. I would never have learned how to program without this degree I am absolutely convinced. Like yeah maybe I could hook some stuff up to an array in python and struggle through a for loop.

The CS degree gave me confidence, expertise in solving CS related problems, and for better or worse the market expects me to have this degree and it helped me land a job where I already make 50% more than median household income in my city at only 27.

I would take that student debt again in a heartbeat.

Two of my friends with 4 year college degrees recently quit their jobs and went back to study CS. I told them to avoid bootcamps, why?

I've been a part of the hiring process and people from bootcamps are usually not very good, but occasionally they are. To me the bootcamp education doesn't guarantee a CS related role. You could end up with nothing.

Even my friends who STRUGGLED through a CS degree and are AWFUL programmers were able to leverage their degree into roles like Project Manager or Product Owner which have great outlooks and solid pay.

Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by 908B64B197 on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:57PM (#25376379)
I've seen a lot of Software Engineering curriculum, and the more serious ones are always CS + Engineering (so semester long projects, projects management) and there was an expectation that the student could build something at the end. Basically, what Stanford/MIT does (and a bunch of others).

On the other hand, I've seen places where the "Software Engineering" is about requirement, methodologies and tools and has no math nor algorithms. That's akin to an aeronautical engineer without a solid background in classical mechanics.

Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by cmrdporcupine on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:19PM (#25375916)
Not sure why you're getting downvoted, I don't think you're wrong. Most industry work is not "computer science" work, but more software mechanics or engineering work. Having the CS background no doubt helps, but having it exclusively is a disadvantage. But it is worth pointing out that there seems to be a great diversity in the content in CS programs, and many schools do emphasize practical industry aspects more than others. Or have aggressive internship programs like U Waterloo, does etc.
Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by petermcneeley on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:24PM (#25375977)
Many have switched to using the title "Software Developer" to avoid this confusion.

Even jobs that specify "Software Engineer" first ask for CS degrees (or equivalent)

The reason for this is that they want people that know computer science (algorithms and such) but people that are not actually scientists.

Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by cmrdporcupine on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:28PM (#25376053)
Switched to? I guess I really am old. This is how almost all jobs were labelled before 10 or so years ago. Somehow "Software Engineer" became standard, probably under the influence of the FAANGs, in the last decade.

It's worth pointing out that here in Google Canada we were recently instructed to start referring to ourselves as Software Developers again, as "Engineer" is at least partially a protected term.

Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by petermcneeley on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:37PM (#25376169)
I wish there was a better term. We are not scientist but not mechanics or engineers either. This isnt a minor question. There is an entirely new set of knowledge workers in the new economy that do not have 19th-20th century equivalents.
Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by cmrdporcupine on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:39PM (#25376185)
"Programmer" and "Programmer analyst" were titles used frequently when I first started getting into the industry. Then "software developer." Honestly, that's mostly what we do... develop and repair software.
Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by 908B64B197 on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:59PM (#25376404)
> It's worth pointing out that here in Google Canada we were recently instructed to start referring to ourselves as Software Developers again, as "Engineer" is at least partially a protected term.

That's a good thing.

Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by 908B64B197 on Thursday December 10, 2020 @04:34PM (#25379034)
I see the downvotes but no explanation!
Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by petermcneeley on Thursday December 10, 2020 @07:43PM (#25380889)
You make a statement without explanation and then when people dismiss it you ask for an explanation. Its very odd behavior. At best I would say it is asymmetric way of thinking.
Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by 908B64B197 on Friday December 11, 2020 @02:33PM (#25389771)
I find that there's an implicit assumption that an engineer will posses certain knowledge. Things like a solid math background, project planning, economics... Also, that they should be able to apply rigorous solutions to problems and be capable of doing root cause analysis.

It's the same thing in the medical field where everyone had the same core courses in med school before choosing their specialty.

I don't think "Front-end engineers" is the correct term to designate someone with a 6 month bootcamp on their resume, because it really breaks all assumptions I've made above.

Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by petermcneeley on Friday December 11, 2020 @03:36PM (#25390633)
I dont disagree. However I do think the 21 century is partially about the breakdown of certifications and professional organizations and a shift to purely merit.

There are people in FAANG the dont even have any post secondary making > 500k a year as "Software Engineers". How this works without total chaos is that each company has a rigorous testing procedure for candidates.

This cataclysm has yet to reach the field of medicine or law but it is sorely needed. (I say this with family in both).

I understand the difficulty and that the term "engineer" probably should never have been used as a substitute for "skilled knowledge worker" but I would expect this kind of deracination to continue till the economic calcification is no more.

Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by 908B64B197 on Friday December 11, 2020 @04:07PM (#25390987)
> There are people in FAANG the dont even have any post secondary making > 500k a year as "Software Engineers". How this works without total chaos is that each company has a rigorous testing procedure for candidates.

That's what I expect from a credible credentialing organization, to be able to tell me that person X meets a minimum bar. Right now they get a bad press because, especially in the medical field, it's more about gate keeping and lobbying than actually enforcing standards and protecting the public.

I would argue that surely someone making that type of money at a world class organization like Google would have no problem passing any engineering exam.

Re:Stories from developers without CS degrees by deeeeplearning on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:14PM (#25375851)
How else will you be able to pass algorithmic whiteboard interviews? Everyone knows that acing those is the only way you can possibly be a good engineer