For the record I would subscribe to the liberal education viewpoint of college but question why that can't be had for free with the resources of the internet at this point.
Note: By liberal education I do not mean politically liberal but rather a term encompassing a full rounded individual akin to a renaissance man, that is familiar with and can discuss language and mathematics just as well as art history or philosophy.
How well is remote schooling working during the pandemic? Now imagine that, but with no teachers at all. Teachers are an important part of the education process.
Whereas those that view college as a tool of securing employment complain about the classes and feel they are a waste of time, resulting in them not getting much out of it anyway.
I agree teachers are important, but does a teacher have to be someone that sits and lectures in a classroom? If I am interested in OS theory I can join the Linux mailing list, ask questions on Linux development forums, heck if I ask a good question I may even have Linus himself take a minute to respond to my question.
Beyond that from my understanding many of the "teachers" at the college level are Grad students assigned to teach a class and that professors view it as a chore.
Not that I am totally against teachers or traditional education, I just think that one can acquire all of the benefits of a liberal education without ever needing to set foot in a classroom in this day and age.
This is a common (and, I suppose, understandably so), but mistaken HN trope: that developers who went to college learned how to program from their professors whereas the non-college types are the scrappy, pull-yourself-up-by-your-bootstraps autodidacts. In reality, I've never even heard of anybody who's completed a CS degree (or any other degree) who works as a developer who didn't also learn independently exactly the same way people who didn't get a four-year degree did. The CS curriculum seems to expect this and instead of focusing on the things that you can realistically learn on your own, focusing on the things that you're probably not going to come across on your own.
This is an excellent point. Almost nobody has an idea of the true depth and breadth of most subjects or how to sequence that learning.