News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first su... by ineedasername on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @09:45PM (#25369010)
Given that it's a rocket, "nearly land" could mean it kept going in some way, towards space or simply not yet touched down.

So when I read the HN title and thought "what do they mean by nearly landed?" I then saw the article and realized "oh, it crashed".

I'm not sure where the balance should be... "Crash" has a negative connotation, but "nearly lands" is a pretty soft euphemism.

Re:SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first su... by ineedasername on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:56PM (#25369909)
To add to my comment-- I think the CNN headline got it better without the softening euphemism by pointing out it was a success: "A SpaceX Mars rocket prototype just exploded. It was still a success"
Re:SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first su... by natch on Thursday December 10, 2020 @01:45AM (#25370595)
I don’t think it exploded. It broke up by hitting the ground (not by exploding) which caused fuel and oxygen to leak out, which then ignited in a large fireball. But maybe this is splitting hairs. It sure looked like an explosion.
Re:SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first su... by ineedasername on Thursday December 10, 2020 @08:41PM (#25381267)
oxygen to leak out, which then ignited in a large fireball.

That sounds a lot like a thermoberic bomb :)

Re:SpaceX launches and nearly lands starship on its first su... by natch on Thursday December 10, 2020 @01:41AM (#25370569)
Landing safely was an unexpected outcome, so it’s remarkable (thus making it into the headline) that it came close to doing so. The right wording is highly context dependent. Here the “nearly landed” phrasing appropriately acknowledges the realistic expectations for the launch by those most in the know, the SpaceX team.

“Crash” would be totally appropriate in a different context with different expectations. But it would make less sense in this case.