News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by joshaidan on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @09:32AM (#2536337)
"Peer-to-peer just eats up your bandwidth, right, it's like the old technology."

This quote intrigues me the most. Is peer-to-peer really bad, and uses a lot of bandwidth, or is it just bad for Google?

Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by delinka on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @09:39AM (#2536363)
That's just spin to make the architecture sound like a bad idea. Yes, p2p anything uses more of your upload bandwidth than any other means of communicating on the 'net. IMO, that's not "bad" because it keeps the tubes all decentralized and more capable of routing around damage. Like it's supposed to do.
Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by tincholio on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @10:42AM (#2536602)
Nope, it's not about that. Skype can, if you're not running behind a NAT, make you a supernode, and in that case you will be routing calls between NAT'ed hosts "on your dime". Basically, it may be that you contribute your bandwidth to calls that have nothing to do with you. Presumably this isn't the case in the "cloud based" service, where the some server would act as a gateway between NAT'ed hosts.
Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by joshaidan on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @12:23PM (#2537045)
Does Skype actually route voice traffic through a supernode? I thought it was just routing TCP/UDP requests to open up ports behind a NAT'd router. As well, supernodes may also be handling some authentication traffic. But I'm not 100% familiar with Skype's protocol.
Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by iki23 on Saturday May 14, 2011 @03:19PM (#2548346)
Yes, supernodes are used to negotiate the communication trough NATs, the method's called UDP hole punching: http://www.google.com/search?num=100&hl=en&q=skype+n...
Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by recoiledsnake on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @11:32AM (#2536804)
They could just easily run a whole bunch of supernodes themselves in the cloud, and turn off the supernode functionality for client ip addressses. I don't see why they make it out to be a big dealbreaker.
Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by tincholio on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @11:44AM (#2536861)
Of course they could, but then it wouldn't be p2p anymore, right?
Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by th on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @12:00PM (#2536935)
I think it could probably still be considered p2p. Skype only falls back to using a supernode if two clients cannot form a connection on their own: http://saikat.guha.cc/pub/iptps06-skype/
Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by tincholio on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @01:20PM (#2537271)
If you read my original comment, that's precisely what I said. Supernodes are used to link NAT'ed hosts. If the supernodes were run by Skype on "the cloud" they wouldn't really be peers anymore, but act as servers. That's what I said in my 2nd post.
Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by bad_user on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @10:46AM (#2536619)
Yes it does, because in addition to your own traffic, your line also has to support the traffic made by other people - with torrents, this means uploading to other people what you've been downloading.

I don't know exactly how much bandwidth Skype uses, but it has been the most reliable way of doing video-chats for me, even on the slow Internet connection I'm using.

Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by joshaidan on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @12:27PM (#2537059)
Yeah, but in these use cases it's using a lot of traffic because the application of file transfer, and voice/video conversations use up a lot of bandwidth.

If we take, for example, an application like Bitcoin, it uses a minimal amount of data transfer because all it's doing is coordinating transactions and mining.

If take a simple use case like P2P text chat, would the bandwidth costs be all that bad compared to a cloud or client-server model?

Re:Why Google Does Not Own Skype by r00fus on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @01:50PM (#2537420)
Likely, it doesn't have anything to do with what's said, but what's unsaid... how would Google monetize that traffic/data and use it to augment their existing services?

If it's all encrypted P2P and supernodes aren't centrally located but randomly distributed throughout the Skype-net.

They couldn't place ads without rewriting the P2P to have more intercept points.

If it is about money, then I think Chan's point does hold. Google would be buying a money losing venture that doesn't fit with their own monetization model and would take years to integrate if at all.